Live data from Hacker News

VirtualBox is garbage

lkml.org

21–30 of 102 posts

Re: VirtualBox is garbage

#21

A slightly less caustic way of saying it would be to say that bug reports from things running on virtual box are garbage.

I read it as being that the hosts themselves are the ones generating garbage bug reports, rather than the virtualized OS's?

Otherwise, yours would be a much better title for this.

Re: VirtualBox is garbage

#23
post #8

Has anyone managed to get Windows 8 running in VirtualBox on OS X? I've tried, keep getting errors.

Yup, worked for me. Have you ticked all the relevant options in the VM Settings?

  First stop in the System menu. Start with the Motherboard
  sub-menu and check Enable IO APIC to improve performance 
  for your virtual machine. In the Processor sub-menu check
  Enable PAE/NX (again, to boost performance). Finally under 
  the Acceleration sub-menu make sure both of the hardware 
  virtualization boxes are checked—VT-x/AMD-V and Nested 
  Paging, respectively.
- Taken from http://www.howtogeek.com/74515/how-to-test-drive-windows-8-i... (which I know is a Windows guide, but check the same settings in OS X)

Re: VirtualBox is garbage

#25
post #11
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think I managed to crash it about ten times last sunday, doing nothing but browsing the web on a VM.

I can't remember the last time I crashed VirtualBox, browsing or not. Even with older 64-bit Flash. Only issue I recall is some snapshot breakage a while back. Yay anecdotes.

Seconded. It's never crashed for me, I love it.

Re: VirtualBox is garbage

#26
Wonder if there's a selection bias here; VirtualBox may be less stable than native hardware or commercial VMs, but it's user base is also using VirtualBox for different scenarios than native users.

I know I use VirtualBox all the time to try out "risky" behaviors that often end in a crash, because I know I can just roll back if it doesn't work out.

Re: VirtualBox is garbage

#27

Virtualbox works fine for me. Though I only use it to run Windows XP so I'm probably not a demanding customer, but calling it garbage is kind of over-the top. It's very useful for me for running some windows-only software that refuses to work in Wine, and to test my sw on windows without having to reboot...

I agree, I run XP and Vista under Virtualbox for testing websites, plus Debian for when I want to guarantee a clean development environment. I've never had any problems, other than with some Windows games which can't detect the CD drive because they assume it will be at D:\

Re: VirtualBox is garbage

#28
I've had quite a few issues with it.

1. Copy + paste randomly breaks between host win32, client ubuntu32.

2. Random freezes every so often.

3. Seamless mode extremely unreliable, does not draw correctly.

4. Horrible issues with shared folders breaking io operations. I actually got a (trivial) patch into golang to work around this issue (!). This also completely breaks ido mode completions in emacs.

5. Occasionally shared folders get into an odd state and no files can be read from/written to them.

4 + 5 might be specific to the way I use shared folders though, as I access them via a dropbox folder sat in a truecrypt volume.

Re: VirtualBox is garbage

#29
post #8

Has anyone managed to get Windows 8 running in VirtualBox on OS X? I've tried, keep getting errors.

Yup, worked for me. Have you ticked all the relevant options in the VM Settings? First stop in the System menu. Start with the Motherboard sub-menu and check Enable IO APIC to improve performance for your virtual machine. In the Processor sub-menu check Enable PAE/NX (again, to boost performance). Finally under the Acceleration sub-menu make sure both of the hardware virtualization boxes are checked—VT-x/AMD-V and Ne…

Hadn't seen those, will give it a shot!

Re: VirtualBox is garbage

#30
post #11
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think I managed to crash it about ten times last sunday, doing nothing but browsing the web on a VM.

I can't remember the last time I crashed VirtualBox, browsing or not. Even with older 64-bit Flash. Only issue I recall is some snapshot breakage a while back. Yay anecdotes.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN