Live data from Hacker News

Why IE will continue to win the enterprise browser wars

weblog.infoworld.com

21–24 of 24 posts

Re: Why IE will continue to win the enterprise browser wars

#21

I agree with the conclusion, but not the logic. A much more likely cause for IE supremacy is an established set of enterprise "web" applications, where these (badly written) "web" applications are so broken outside IE that they might as well be Win32. If executives sank money into applications that now run the business, and find that IE keeps those applications running, they're more likely to establish an easy policy…

Wait. Why would an enterprise want to make an only internally used application a web application? It both takes longer to write and usually is slower to use (very mouse-oriented, unless designed really smartly) than a good desktop application. Of course I'm not talking about those kind of desktop applications where someone pulls a database table onto a form in Delphi or Visual Studio - those aren't better or written faster than web applications.

No, what I mean is that most enterprises have an ERP system which comes with it's own, quite efficient domain-specific language and development environment, so when they figure out that f.e. they need a system to reserve projectors for presentations, the easiest way is to develop it right inside the ERP system. Or use something similar to these efficient ERP development environments, such as FoxPro.

Why would you put your application on the web when the point isn't to be able to use it from a netcafe, but it is used only by people sitting in an office and keying in data all day long?

Re: Why IE will continue to win the enterprise browser wars

#22

I agree with the conclusion, but not the logic. A much more likely cause for IE supremacy is an established set of enterprise "web" applications, where these (badly written) "web" applications are so broken outside IE that they might as well be Win32. If executives sank money into applications that now run the business, and find that IE keeps those applications running, they're more likely to establish an easy policy…

[deleted]

Re: Why IE will continue to win the enterprise browser wars

#23

I agree with the conclusion, but not the logic. A much more likely cause for IE supremacy is an established set of enterprise "web" applications, where these (badly written) "web" applications are so broken outside IE that they might as well be Win32. If executives sank money into applications that now run the business, and find that IE keeps those applications running, they're more likely to establish an easy policy…

Can you point to at least one "established set of enterprise "web" applications" that supports this claim?

https://www.pwccomperio.com

(go there in any browser except IE). This is pretty much the case for all PwC webapps. PwC = >25,000 U.S. employees.

Re: Why IE will continue to win the enterprise browser wars

#24
post #20

I'm not a network admin but I don't quite understand his logic... why can't you enforce group policy on a higher level (something like how OpenDNS can filter specific sets of sites)? Am I missing something?

IE's Group Policy encompasses a whole lot more than which particular sites the web browser is allowed to visit. http://www.ie-vista.com/group_policy.html

most of IE policy control seems shallow except for permission to modify settings...
Post reply on HN