Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

bionic-reading.com

261–270 of 281 posts

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#261

This presumes you're scanning lines but if you really want to speed read you should scan whole blocks of text as you draw the eye down, there should be little to no horizontal movement when you're really reading fast. - - - - An interesting and effective method of speed reading is Rapid Serial Visual Presentation (RSVP). These days it's mostly used in the context of psychological/perception studies, but it came about…

> There's an interesting effect where you can take some text and, for each word longer than ~5 letters [...] I think you're referring to this (dubbed "Typoglycemia"): > Aoccdrnig to rscheearch at Cmabrigde uinervtisy, it deosn't mttaer waht oredr the ltteers in a wrod are [...] It's sort of true (although there was never any research at Cambridge that anyone has been able to unearth), but it's way more limited that "…

Ah! Well met! Thank you for digging that up and posting it.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#262

I have some feedback regarding the testimonial from “Sangeeth”, whose Memoji shows a Sikh person. Did the user choose their Memoji? The two don’t go together well for reasons of odd cultural differences in the Roman/Latin transliteration of sounds in the south and the north of India. The -th- cluster represents the dental t, IPA /t/, but only in South India. In the North the same sound is represented by -t-. Therefor…

Hi kranner I didn't mean to offend you. Or misrepresent the culture with a memoji. Sorry. If you feel it's out of order, then I can change it too. But what is more crucial for me is what Sangeeth said. And that is more important to me. By the way, all testimonials are real. 100%

Hi renato_casutt, I'm not offended at all and congratulations on launching. I only commented to point out that the turban+name combination makes the comment look inauthentic which may be an issue in the intended use of the comment as social proof.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#263
post #250

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let's just take the emojis away if we all can't get along with them.

It certainly seems clear that renato_cassutt, who it is clear can taken constructive criticism and who has given very useful replies throughout the comments, meant no-one any harm; and neither I nor, I am sure, kranner meant to impute any ill intent. I can understand the appeal of pictorial representations of one's users; I was just, and I suspect that kranner was also, trying to mention the possible inadvertent offe…

Thanks JadeNB. I'm pretty sure that renato_cassutt didn't mean any harm and that the testimonial is from a real user. The context that many are missing here is that a turban is religious headwear like a yarmulke. As a Sikh you have to be authorised to wear one in a ceremony called a "dastaarbandi", and there are rules of conduct while wearing one in public. It's inadvisable to add one to the depiction of a person unless they choose it themselves. This kind of thing (e.g. inappropriate Sikh representation in movies) regularly becomes a political issue in India. In renato_cassutt's case, it's an unnecessary distraction from the actual product.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#264
post #216

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There’s probably some sort of important lesson here…

Maybe, but Sangeeth is not here to tell us if they are Sikh or not, so it's hard to say. I think it's unfortunate that (at the time of writing) the comments about the product and its effectiveness are ranked lower than this discussion about the _possibility_ that a non-Sikh person has been represented as Sikh. If Sangeeth themselves had popped up in this thread to comment on the choice of emoji, then sure, but it's j…

Sangeeth is not a Sikh name. In India people don't convert to Sikhism, or at least I'm a middle-aged Indian and I've lived here all my life, I've never seen it happen. There's a certain foreign subculture of Americans converting to Sikhism, but then they take on Sikh names. It's extremely improbable that Sangeeth is a Sikh person.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#265
post #226

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am alone and I put all my money, time and work into BR. Visible is only a small part. But I think everyone decides for themselves what is best. But thank you for the critical feedback.

You put all your money, time and work into bolding the first few letters of a word?

Did you think of it? The author spent money, time, and work in R&D for a process that seems simple but is novel.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#266
For everyone who think this is new stuff: It is not new. There was another company in the German speaking space, Vienna more exactly, see craftworks.at, that offered almost the exact same product already back in 2019, perhaps even earlier, also called "Bionic Reading". In the current version of the website this does not appear, but it is saved in archive.org: https://web.archive.org/web/20190119032121/http://br.craftwo...

Perhaps the author of the current offering worked at craftworks at that time, then left and took his IP with him, I don't know.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#267
post #63
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, I agree. I guess this technology isn't for everyone. This is a real bummer. They did not have to patent and trademark this method, which in principle is such a basic mechanism. Just had to productize their service really well so they'd take the lead in monetizing.

I disagree 100%. This is amazingly innovative. We have seen letter switching examples and how the brain will try to fill in the gaps. This is superbly unique and justifiably a patent and trademark. The demo works. The rules may be simple. But as the old boat repairman story says, sometimes you need to know where to hit the hammer. Please, please don't use this for evil.

Just FYI, as I detailed in my top-level comment: While it is a really nice tool, it is already a few years old, so I'm not sure if it qualifies as innovative. See: https://web.archive.org/web/20190119032121/http://br.craftwo...

More info detailed at my top-level comment.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#268

The rules implemented are very simple (taken from the patent application [1], the exact numbers are configurable). If there are 4 letters, 40% of all letters are bold. There is this claim as the first text on the website: We are happy if as many people as possible can use the advantage of Bionic Reading. For this reason, Bionic Reading should be able to be integrated into existing apps and services. The benefit for t…

Because these folks deserve to eat and pay rent for a few years upon discovering something so useful.

I have mentioned this a few times here already, but I will mention it again, even if I risk looking like a spammer, as it seems this point hans't been made strongly enough in this thread: This discovery is not new.

A different company published almost an identical product more than 3 years ago (see https://web.archive.org/web/20190119032121/http://br.craftwo... as well as my top-level comment).

So I am absolutely against patenting something that is 1) not new 2) that has a very simple implementation and could thus easily be disseminated widely if patents weren't "protecting" it. Reminds me strongly of the various patent wars regarding scrolling on the smartphone and other simple user interface gestures; in the end everyone looses out.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#269

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because these folks deserve to eat and pay rent for a few years upon discovering something so useful.

If we expect everyone to innovate and build useful tools solely out of the goodness of their heart, then we can expect far fewer useful tools & innovations in the future.

I think the opposite is true. Patents are hampering further progress that would built upon the innovation or make use of it to increase productivity. but said progress often is not happening, if the costs of obtaining a license is high, or if first tedious communication has to happen with the author to obtain green light to use his invention. Rapid innovation looks different.

If you innovate without filing a patent, you get a head start. The time the you have until other catch on - that is how you can monetize your invention.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#270
post #134

This reminds me of BeeLine Reader: https://www.beelinereader.com/

BeeLine founder here; interested to see this. My first reaction was that the "before" text in the before/after demonstration is both thin and grey. It is well known that text that is too thin and too light-colored is not great to read. The text modification shown here makes certain letters easier to read, but it appears this is partially because the rest of the text is specifically difficult to read. The background o…

Since you work in this field, I'd be interested if you would really qualify this as innovation. I have posted already in several places in this thread about the fact that Bionic Reader is at least 3 years old already. Someone else also dug up the patent application: The rules to make the text bold in Bionic Reader in its simplest form (i.e. ignoring things like setting Saccade manually) apparently is just a very very simple if-else that takes 3 lines of code.

Also, have you patented BeeLine as well?

Post reply on HN