Live data from Hacker News

Windows needs a change in priorities

den.dev

541–550 of 884 posts

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#541
post #311

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless you care about gaming MacOS has been rock solid for at least a decade. For what it is worth I am no mac fanboy, I am typing this to you on a windows 10 computer in my shop(that I use for gaming, among other things).

Yeah, this. Macos is my daily driver and it does a good job of staying out of my way. I recently got a windows pc just for gaming, and god DAMN it's annoying. Even worse than Vista. Nothing is consistent anymore and everything is always trying to grab my attention for irrelevant shit. What the hell happened :/

As a long time Windows user, I highly recommend using this to turn off the useless crap.

https://github.com/Disassembler0/Win10-Initial-Setup-Script

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#542
post #299
post #250

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Linux still barely works in 2022 I have had zero problem running linux as my daily driver for the last 10 years, care to explain your comment? The only problem that I have is that video games don't always work because the developers don't care.

I see this argument in every thread about Linux. There's always this one magical user where everything "just works", has had 0 issues and everything's just dandy.

Linux is not a 0 issue OS, but I use roughly the same methods and reasoning to get it to workable state as I might on Windows 10 and I wouldn't say it even takes much longer. Linux is surely cheaper. The difference is, Linux can keep growing in the direction you want and choose.

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#543
post #537
post #477

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The current MacOS desktop environment is, generously, a dumpster fire. But it’s also miles ahead of anything else on the market. The last decade of desktop environments feels like a march backwards, or perhaps even vertical, into some kind of alternate reality where the UI is designed to get in the way instead of enable. Modern desktop environments are a painful death by a thousand cuts. This is a rant but a desktop…

All I want is macOS with window snapping and a maximise button. Their absence makes shifting from Windows very difficult. I can't understand why these basic features have not been added, yet the OS receives changes that, as you rightly point out, tend to defile the user experience. I can't understand why people would want to make windows full screen in ordinary situations. It seems to be something I would only want t…

To be clear, I think the power in a windowing desktop environment is not having to maximize windows. That’s a compromise for small screens. When I upgraded my 2014 RMBP to Big Sur I lost the ability to compose multiple windows because of the grotesque enlargement of the window header.

The ability to snap to fill the screen may be useful on tiny screens but with Mac hardware shouldn’t be as important because the real estate (pixels!) should be there to use and arrange individual windows. Even multiple windows per app.

Modern MacOS (post OSX) got away from the classic MacOS (<=9) workflow and now occupies an awkward position of having the worst characteristics of Windows, Gnome, and OSX.

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#544
post #483

I don't see any mention of Cortana or how hard that is to rip out of the OS, but I think it's worth mentioning. The tool called "Everything" by https://www.voidtools.com/ is so insanely better than Cortana and blazingly fast that I'm not sure why they're still trying to push Cortana. https://www.getblackbird.net/ helps a lot and it's one of the first things I do to Windows installs when I need to use them, but it can…

Blackbird gets blocked by Defender immediately. Not sure why I'm surprised. edit: Then again, that tool does seem to make it quite easy to damage your Windows installation.

I don't trust it because it is a closed source binary and there is a lack of detailed documentation of exactly what settings it changes.

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#545

Some of the anti-user patterns aren't even pioneered by Microsoft, they simply fall in the anti-user direction many big companies are pushing. Ads in apps? Pioneered in Android. Tricking the user to log in using Microsoft account? You can't make much use of an Android phone unless you sign in with your google account. Also, Apple requests having an Apple Id. I wonder what if someone at Apple, Google, Microsoft decide…

> You can't make much use of an Android phone unless you sign in with your google account.

This depends on the phone. Samsung phones aren’t terribly bad, I’ve been using one without google account for a few months now. For instance, the built-in web browser has a command like “setup an ad blocker”.

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#547
post #492

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't say it was going to save me. I do think I had a type that said 'good future.' I meant to put something along the lines of 'good probability of a future.' Chrome OS is going to be another user hostile environment for sure. But the point is, Chrome OS has a good shot at displacing windows not because it is better or less user hostile, but because it is putting cheap machines in the hands of kids who will one d…

Purchasing decision are made by business executives. I use windows because i am forced by my employer.

you can do like I do, use window for nothing beside virtual box in which there's your real everyday OS.

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#548

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I recently got Apex Legends working and it's running perfectly at 144 fps in 2k on a 1080 ti. I've also played FFXIV and Path of Exile extensively in Linux. The only thing left is Adobe products which is honestly a matter of time. Just really takes hammering out some market share until Adobe relents. A lot of the best kernel, driver, and gui shell improvements have only really hit their stride in the past 24 months.…

> A lot of the best kernel, driver, and gui shell improvements have only really hit their stride in the past 24 months. Could you elaborate on that? I've been using desktop Linux almost exclusively for the past 24 years (ouch!), and recent years seem pretty average to me. Things work great, most of the time, like always. Unless you're talking about gaming. I'm not a gamer (or i wouldn't be such a long time Linux user…

Gaming was what held me back from switching for decades. Steam is doing a great job on that front, most recent (like in max 5 years old) games in my library work like a charm under Ubuntu. And that includes all AAA games. Old games are harder as those are, understandably, not on top of the priority list to convert to Linux. For those, and some rarely used other stuff I haven't bothered to figure out Linux alternatives for, I still use Windows.

If Linux based gaming continues on the current trajectory, I could imagine a world in which a great chunk of the consumer market switches from Windows to Linux.

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#549

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> You don't understand because you're failing to empathize with what people are saying, because it's not a problem you personally experience. To be clear I support my wife's LTSC install and use Windows 11 with WSL and WSLg for work. > I don't think even the LTSC edition avoids the UX problems discussed here. I think it does but please highlight which problems it doesnt avoid. > suppose you find a shoe manufacturer t…

>I think it does but please highlight which problems it doesnt avoid. I've never used it, I was guessing based on my understanding of what LTSC is. >Do they respect me as a user? What are their capital incentives? If not aligned with mine why do I love them? The thing you love is the shoes, not the shoes' manufacturer. >Can I change my purchasing habits so their capital incentives align? Can you, as in, is it possibl…

> Are you implying that the natural tendency of a product is to get worse until it's no better than its competitors?

Yes! And I'll get a little philosophical here but if we really take an eagle's eye view on the source of this problem it's that capitalism insists on growth to keep the machine of prosperity running. On a microcosmic scale you can see this at work inside companies, which must pursue new growth streams as existing markets become saturated. With single digit growth in OS licenses, Microsoft pursues cloud/Office/SaaS to continue offering investors big returns. This leads to the inevitable downward spiral of the quality of former core products and desperate moves to monetize essentially a delivery vehicle to sell SaaS products.

Stepping outside Microsoft for a moment and looking at Apple we can already see this emergent behavior in Apple's pivot to services and the marketing of those services inside its SaaS/subscription delivery vehicles, such as iCloud+, Apple TV, Arcade etc.

Returning to Microsoft, this is why we see Windows licenses now being sold basically for free and Microsoft removing virtually all burdens to a user running an unlicensed OS. It no longer matters to their new core business.

Given this duopoly of OSes with a new service fetish it behooves a user of these OSes to either pay so much money to Microsoft for respectful OS editions they can't help but notice (volume licensing LTSC) or explore alternatives that aren't beholden to these vicious imperatives.

Re: Windows needs a change in priorities

#550
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The whole OS market is pretty rough right now. This is my feeling over the past few years. No OS is in a great spot. But I have hopes for Linux being better supported with Valve using it on the Steam Deck. (Not the highest hopes, but more hope than I used to have)

I don't play videogames and I'm perfectly fine with my Ubuntu install, it does everything I need it to do. Only gamers put videogaming as a must for an operating system.

And that is getting constantly better with Linus as well, thanks to Steam.
Post reply on HN