Live data from Hacker News

Meld is a visual diff and merge tool targeted at developers

meldmerge.org

81–90 of 146 posts

Re: Meld is a visual diff and merge tool targeted at developers

#81

IMHO, Meld is the second best open source tool for doing this. On Windows, WinMerge[1] is a better alternative. Too bad is Windows only. For a non-FOSS and cross platform solution I recommend BeyondCompare (U$30.00)[2]. It replicates most of WinMerge UI. [1] https://winmerge.org/ [2] https://scootersoftware.com/

winmerge is definitely the best windows-only open source app I've used. surprised it's never been ported to linux.

Re: Meld is a visual diff and merge tool targeted at developers

#83
I purchased Araxis Merge but I still find myself using Meld for the vast, vast majority of my 2- and 3- way Diffing.

It’s slightly tricky to integrate into Sourcetree but once you configure Sourcetree with the correct command line args it works quite painlessly.

Meld is extremely performant too.

Another text editor I love is “010 Editor”, it’s the only windows app I’ve found that works well on 2+ GB files without slowing my computer down.

Re: Meld is a visual diff and merge tool targeted at developers

#84

IMHO, Meld is the second best open source tool for doing this. On Windows, WinMerge[1] is a better alternative. Too bad is Windows only. For a non-FOSS and cross platform solution I recommend BeyondCompare (U$30.00)[2]. It replicates most of WinMerge UI. [1] https://winmerge.org/ [2] https://scootersoftware.com/

I actually don't understand what people love about BC. The only thing I find it extremely useful for is the occasional files where inline diffs are practically mandatory, like CSVs. Other than that, I generally find it frustrating compared to TortoiseGitMerge, except perhaps for some very specific/unusual scenarios. In particular the line highlighting is annoying - instead of coloring the lines that were added vs. re…

+1 for TortoiseGitMerge, which is my go-to tool these days. It's Windows only but not a problem for me since I mostly work in Windows.

My SO adores Meld, but she works with Linux. I tried using it but couldn't get used to it. She also makes fun of me (half in jest) because I use Tortoise Git instead of the command line...

Re: Meld is a visual diff and merge tool targeted at developers

#86

Maybe strange question; but which diff and merge tools are not targeted at developers? Edit: what->which

Wikipedia, Google Docs, Microsoft Word... they're far simpler systems, but still useful for everyday edits

These have some diff functionality but are not "diff / merge tools". There are diff tools, though, targeted at lawyers for legal work: "show me the differences between these two contracts" and the such (which most developer-oriented tools actually suck at as they care too much about "lines" and whitespace).

Re: Meld is a visual diff and merge tool targeted at developers

#87

IMHO, Meld is the second best open source tool for doing this. On Windows, WinMerge[1] is a better alternative. Too bad is Windows only. For a non-FOSS and cross platform solution I recommend BeyondCompare (U$30.00)[2]. It replicates most of WinMerge UI. [1] https://winmerge.org/ [2] https://scootersoftware.com/

I actually don't understand what people love about BC. The only thing I find it extremely useful for is the occasional files where inline diffs are practically mandatory, like CSVs. Other than that, I generally find it frustrating compared to TortoiseGitMerge, except perhaps for some very specific/unusual scenarios. In particular the line highlighting is annoying - instead of coloring the lines that were added vs. re…

The things that makes it borderline useless to you is actually one reason I like it so much. Makes it really easy to do code reviews and focus on what actually matters. Also, it was until somewhat recently the undisputed best 3-way merge tool. Meld gets close, but to me Meld's UI is sluggish and fuzzy (on Windows) while BC is snappy and sharp.

Re: Meld is a visual diff and merge tool targeted at developers

#89

Kaleidoscope on macOS isn’t cheap but has a great DX.

I too wish Kaleidoscope wasn't quite so expensive. I've had my eye on since the v3 rewrite but can't bring myself to spend $150 on a tool I'll only use occasionally. I wish there was a "lite" version for $50.

Re: Meld is a visual diff and merge tool targeted at developers

#90
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wikipedia, Google Docs, Microsoft Word... they're far simpler systems, but still useful for everyday edits

These have some diff functionality but are not "diff / merge tools". There are diff tools, though, targeted at lawyers for legal work: "show me the differences between these two contracts" and the such (which most developer-oriented tools actually suck at as they care too much about "lines" and whitespace).

I don't think it's that black and white? Google Docs, for example, lets you individually review and accept/deny/revise each individual suggested change. It's not a 3-way merge like programmers are used to seeing, but it's the same idea... you start with an original, see someone else's changes, and decide which to keep, or you can take their changes and further edit. And comment in-line too.

I've never used a lawyer's diff tool, but my IDE (IntelliJ) ignores whitespace and lines.

Post reply on HN