Live data from Hacker News

Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

annoying.technology

231–240 of 288 posts

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#231
post #215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How does building closed source products fight open source? They’re not at odds with each other.

Because either you're struggling for human progress doing research and building tech that empowers people, or you're struggling for profit building harmful tech for the common people. Apple is in the latter category (to be fair, most if not all hardware/software manufacturers are) and has shown time and time again that they were strongly opposed to consumer rights: - pushing updates to slow down older iOS to "encoura…

Sounds like you only read the headlines and not actually use any of their products

Also really? you are either all-loving-god or the devil, no greys for you

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#232

There are some battery draining tricks you can do with Bluetooth apps on a phone to drain the device batteries. Essentially if you did a ton of device queries to every BLE device visible, you could drain the batteries of every device in range. Transmission is probably a heavier battery drain so just making them talk to your phone creates drain. It’s a single device example, but in a bar once I was showing a co-worker…

Another thing that's basically a real security hole/opportunity with BLE sniffing is to record the unique IDs of all the BLE devices you can see, along with geo-location data. Do this enough places and over time, and you get a map of what devices are where and at what time, with the assumption that the devices are probably linked to people. Expand that to a government placing little innocuous BLE sniffers all over th…

Why bother with sniffers? Just ask apple and google for their list along with tue identity of the person.

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#233
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I haven't found anything that compares to even a middling wired boom mic. Wireless has too much latency and non-boom has too much noise. The only thing better is an actual VoIP phone (eg Polycom).

It is polarizing though. There are a lot of people who will get positively offended at the notion that their wireless earbuds are not perfect. One of the things that biases is that they hear the others OK, so assume the earbuds are fine. What needs digging is to understand that when somebody has open mike like that, most meeting software engages heavy noise reduction or even half-duplex conversation; so there's a lot…

Oh man, the half-duplex conversation is terrible. If people start cutting off whenever someone else speaks, I tell them to wear headphones, but I really don't understand how headphones + push-to-talk isn't standard for everyone by now.

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#234

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is what I'm worried about. Sooner or later we'll need regulation to prevent devices from requiring network connection. I don't think we'll ever get it though.

More likely we will get regulation making smart, connected devices mandatory for one reason or another.

>for one reason or another.

energy consumption

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#235

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And we still wonder why misinformation moves so much faster than truth. It has to be some kind of emotional thing. How many people just saw the headline, immediately decided it must be true, and will now be sure to mention it any time someone mentions AirTags in the future. I doubt this is exactly a new phenomenon, but it sure seems surprising the human race has made it as far as we have successfully.

To be fair, you've fallen into the same trap. One person says they don't have a problem, you believe them and start saying the first statement must be misinformation. It's possible that both people are correct and the circumstances that cause the battery to drain require being connected to a AirTag, not just near any old AirTag. Or there are other circumstances that cause the battery to drain.

I've had some broadcast-happy wifi light bulbs drain iOS devices because they are on the same SSID and vlan. I'm pretty sure running Home Assistant with some random open source plugin the actual issue. Turning off the light bulbs fixed the battery drain. Eventually I just moved the iOS devices to another SSID and vlan, which was a better fix.

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#236
post #215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How does building closed source products fight open source? They’re not at odds with each other.

Because as long as you can do one, you have no reason to do the other if you are not philosophically inclined to. They are absolutely at odds with each other.

> if you are not philosophically inclined to

You can be pushed by shareholders/public opinion, in the same way they get pushed to be environmentally or privacy conscious

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#237
post #171

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except they're not aware of the cost to them so it's not actually consent, and I can't stop them from sending apple or google a message to help track me if i turn one of my bluetooth devices on.

What is the threshold for how informed someone must be in order to be allowed to give consent or make their own decisions here? What responsibility would you place on Apple here versus on the consumers of its devices, specifically? More than likely if you ask for more than what exists what will actually happen is that another blurb will show up in the long terms of service that most people don't read and people aren'…

Don't operate something you've sold to someone remotely for your own benefit with explicit opt in that is difficult to do without understanding. Full stop. Don't mine their device for data. Don't harvest anything at all from it without an explicit interaction or intentional manually configured automation.

So far, far, far away from where google/apple/ms have drawn it.

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#238

I dislike how companies are not only pushing proprietary mesh networks, but also making them automatically enabled for their users and opt-out. It feels like the companies are piggybacking on my internet connection, hardware and electricity for free to literally power their closed network. I don't get paid a penny for it, but their shareholders sure do. Open mesh networks could be really cool, but instead of open net…

> it feels like they are using my internet connection, hardware and electricity for free

That's exactly what they're doing

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#239

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Things broadcasting on WiFi can drain an iPad. I have some WiFi light bulbs and they are pretty noisy. I had to put my iPads on a separate vlan to keep them from draining in a few days of standby. My Mac laptops don’t have this issue. I think it’s because they are configured to not awake up on standby unless plugged in.

Now that's an interesting one. I'm glad I haven't run into that. I've got ~50 noisy little wifi switches in my house, but it hasn't affected my iPad battery life. -knock on wood-

I'm 90% sure Home Assistant is waking up the bulbs more than necessary. (Yay random open source plugins!) It's not a problem for anything else on the network.

Re: Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by

#240
post #231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because either you're struggling for human progress doing research and building tech that empowers people, or you're struggling for profit building harmful tech for the common people. Apple is in the latter category (to be fair, most if not all hardware/software manufacturers are) and has shown time and time again that they were strongly opposed to consumer rights: - pushing updates to slow down older iOS to "encoura…

Sounds like you only read the headlines and not actually use any of their products Also really? you are either all-loving-god or the devil, no greys for you

> Sounds like you only read the headlines and not actually use any of their products

How are these two things connected with the partent's post?

>you are either all-loving-god or the devil, no greys for you

No, but Apple is certainly a dark kind of grey: https://www.fsf.org/news/the-problems-with-apple-arent-just-....

Post reply on HN