Live data from Hacker News

Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

fsf.org

71–80 of 209 posts

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#71

I have said this before: this is a losing battle for individuals striving to protect the freedom, if we just try to do it individually. People bringing this get paid to do this during office time (and maybe after office time too by lobbyists) so they will keep at this; my protests require me to do it by taking time out of the limited time I have left after office. Fight fire with fire, fund EFF so that we have our ow…

[deleted]

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#72
It's even better when you say: hey remember those videos of Russian police stopping people and demanding that they get to search peoples messages? If EARN IT had passed then the Russian government could just remotely search everyone's message history. The arguments about "only legal" access fail miserably. (This is before we consider the copious examples of illegal searches by the US government)

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Without it the criminals WILL have access to your systems and data Replacing criminals and state overreach with foreign adversaries may be more salient. Our encryption debate came of age after the Cold War. The boogeymen of that era have been surpassed. We have new ones, and they're more sinister than thieves and more tangible than a your government turning on you.

> Replacing criminals and state overreach with foreign adversaries may be more salient. For you and me, certainly. For the members of Congress you need to convince of this? They ARE the state. Outside of a few ideological libertarians, protecting the people from the state is not on their agenda.

Those would be the same ones demanding christian based laws?

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#75
I've just read Orwell's 1984 (finally). There is an episode there: "Winston covered his face with his hands. 'Smith! Prisoner 6079!' yelled the telescreen, 'Uncover your face! No faces covered in the cells!" The Big Brother wants to see expressions on your face at all times, and encryption lets you cover it when you have ungood thoughts.

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do politicians even read these letters?

Wrote to a state legislator regarding a specific bill. They voted opposite of what I requested, then wrote back giving a synopsis of the bill and mentioning it passed without even mentioning their vote against the bill.

One time they sent back a letter assuming I opposed a position that I actually supported. In fact, I think the senator supported it too, but probably only got letters from people opposing it.

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#77

Wrote to Dianne Feinstein of CA about being against Earn-IT act and got a letter back about how Earn IT act would prevent child sexual abuse material online. Sigh. As disappointed as I was in the response, I'm glad that EFF makes it really easy to reach out to reps. Took me less than a minute to send out my stance against the Earn IT act to my representatives https://act.eff.org/action/stop-the-earn-it-act-to-save-ou…

Do politicians even read these letters?

No. But staffers do.

Some interesting stuff here:

https://www.wired.com/story/opengov-report-congress-constitu...

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#78

Wrote to Dianne Feinstein of CA about being against Earn-IT act and got a letter back about how Earn IT act would prevent child sexual abuse material online. Sigh. As disappointed as I was in the response, I'm glad that EFF makes it really easy to reach out to reps. Took me less than a minute to send out my stance against the Earn IT act to my representatives https://act.eff.org/action/stop-the-earn-it-act-to-save-ou…

Feinstein has always been anti-encryption and pro-three-letter-agencies.

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#79
post #22

I'm not even a US/UK/EU citizen. Is there any way I can contribute? Or do I just sit and watch the world burn as policymakers elsewhere indirectly make policies that might inadvertently affect people far far away as well?

Donate to the EFF: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/01/congress-must-stop-gra...

Re: Earn-IT threatens encryption and therefore user freedom

#80

Wrote to Dianne Feinstein of CA about being against Earn-IT act and got a letter back about how Earn IT act would prevent child sexual abuse material online. Sigh. As disappointed as I was in the response, I'm glad that EFF makes it really easy to reach out to reps. Took me less than a minute to send out my stance against the Earn IT act to my representatives https://act.eff.org/action/stop-the-earn-it-act-to-save-ou…

Do politicians even read these letters?

They almost certainly do not. However they do count them (well, maybe the intern counts them, but they are counted). And if the counts get big enough, they do start paying attention.
Post reply on HN