Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

news.ycombinator.com

101–110 of 1001 posts

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#101
Maybe bullshit theory: there have been studies where they make sheep deficient in b-vitamins and then let them out on pasture. The results of these studies (which I read about second hand and haven't looked at myself. Might be bullshit science) is that the deficient sheep looks for b-vitamin I och foods like alfaalfa to much greater extent than a non-deficient control group.

I stopped eating fortified foods, changed my diet a bit and started getting cravings for leaf parsley and lentils.

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#102
It's not that weird, but I stopped eating meat during lent a few years ago. I'm not religious, but here in Austria, many non-religious people abstain from something during lent (sweets, alcohol, cigarettes...), so I tried it for myself.

I actually didn't expect much to happen, but it completely changed my diet. It was the first time I actually had to think about what to eat, and it turned out, that I ate a ton of meat, and not a lot of vegetables.

For the first few weeks it was pretty hard to find something to eat, but it got easier. Over time I discovered more vegetarian recipes I actually enjoy.

I'm not a vegetarian, but nowadays I hardly eat any meat, and still do the meatless lent every year. I lost about 15kg in the year after the first lent, and held this weight every since.

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#103
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

any unhealthy side effects of only eating one meal a day? what if that meal is 1800+ calories?

Intermitted fasting works on the principle that if you eat 1800kcal in one sitting you are going to puke. I can easily eat even 3000-4000kcal in 1 day, but in one meal going over 1500kcal is very hard. Edit: Yes I'm wrong I should have said "if you eat 1800kcal of clean food", I forgot the existence of fast food because it is not something common in my country

A personal anecdote but I eat ~1600-1700 kcal each meal. I've been eating one meal a day for years. This is simply because I don't get hungry until around dinner time.

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#104
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

any unhealthy side effects of only eating one meal a day? what if that meal is 1800+ calories?

Intermitted fasting works on the principle that if you eat 1800kcal in one sitting you are going to puke. I can easily eat even 3000-4000kcal in 1 day, but in one meal going over 1500kcal is very hard. Edit: Yes I'm wrong I should have said "if you eat 1800kcal of clean food", I forgot the existence of fast food because it is not something common in my country

A McDonalds Deluxe Cheeseburger, Large Coke and Fries is 1400Kcal - switch to a milkshake or add a McFlurry and your meal is approaching 2000.

https://www.mcdonalds.com/us/en-us/about-our-food/nutrition-...

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#105
Metformin is known to work (a little) and seems to have a longevity effect that no-one understands.

Orlistat works, as long as you can live your life near a toilet.

Semaglutide - looks very promising.

Gastric sleeving and other surgical intervensions are also known to work.

----

Changes to oxygen levels due to altitude are still being researched. Higher altitudes in the USA and Europe correlate with lower levels of obesity at statistically significant levels; higher altitudes in Australia correlate with higher levels of obesity. No-one knows why.

----

Most of the other advice in this thread has a very low probability of succeeding. There will be a lot of selection bias in this thread because the only people responding are the ones for whom it succeeded.

Most of the time for most people, interventions that focus on diet fail.

Interventions that focus on exercise average around 1-2 kg of weight loss in the general population. That said, if you aren't doing any exercise at the moment, then you can reduce your all-cause mortality pretty rapidly with a small amount of exercise (that would definitely fit into your lifestyle). Even if exercise doesn't help you lose weight, it improves your overall cardiac fitness, and that is probably the most important thing to work on.

You asked for weird tips... it seems that if you have the genetic factors that give you a higher predisposition towards obesity, then exercise will work better for you than average.

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#106
Intermittent fasting and writing down what you eat religiously worked for me. Use an app to keep track on your phone: Fastic, Noom, LoseIt, etc. Some people go with other diets like ketogenic diets, those work too.

Another option is to ask your doctor about semaglutide (e.g., Wegovy). Here is a study: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 (Health insurance usually covers it. They have a coupon to bring down the copay to $25.)

The key is consistency and recognizing that you may be eating for reasons other than hunger.

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#107
post #97

Diet change is probably the most important for weight loss. But for getting into a routine of exercising my weird tip would be: Get yourself an Meta Quest 2 and install Thrill of the Fight, Pistol Whip, probably Beat Saber. If you're like me and you dislike the monotony of "normal" cardio exercise, this will make it easy to get your daily dose. Somehow the immersion and gamification allow me to push myself harder tha…

The first time i saw Beat Saber i was pretty convinced this would be the ultimate weight loss game for me. Unfortunately a VR device it's way too expensive for me at the moment.

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#108
Get ADHD meds. Appetite suppression is an effect. :P

Joking aside, the path to losing weight is not dieting, but changing what and how you eat permanently. Weight is an equilibrium, and to reach a new equilibrium, you need to change something about your habits permanently or you'll just bounce back once you stop "dieting". For me personally, reducing sugars and filler carbohydrates was the most effective change to make.

On top of changing how you eat, exercise and strength training can help by making you generally healthier or by making you look slimmer when your muscles strengthen, and of course muscles require more energy to maintain so muscle mass will affect things as well.

Re: Ask HN: Any weird tips for weight loss?

#110
Eat the same food every single day. Same amount, Same everything. Basically you prepared a meal list that is your calories budget of your target weight. Say 1800 calories. You prep a meal that you actually like to eat, and are willing to eat it every single day. By not having the option to choose something else. You keep it simple, the same calories. If you dont mind eating steak every day, or burger every day. Then Burger it is. Avoid Deep fried food though, but if you do your calculation you will soon realise 1800 calories per day doesn't actually give you much option.

Walking at least 35 min per day. No need to do running. Just walk. Go out, walks some places, window shopping, walk you dog. Whatever, walk. 35 min minimum.

You get result within 30 days.

Post reply on HN