Live data from Hacker News

The Great Cul-De-Sac Problem And How To Alleviate It.

chrisnorstrom.com

21–30 of 138 posts

Re: The Great Cul-De-Sac Problem And How To Alleviate It.

#23

I've lived on a dead-end street (but not a cul-de-sac), and I've lived on a regular traffic street. I definitely preferred the dead-end with the lack of traffic and noise, and ability for kids to play in the street without fear of a car going 50 down it. And people did socialize with neighbors on the dead-end street (although maybe not as much as the regular street).

I've never lived in a cul-de-sac (which btw is french for a dead-end street), but spent my childhood playing outside all the same. Narrow, one-way streets, with plenty of speed bumps. I walked to school. Currently I reside downtown, overlooking rails (the trains go quite slowly and make a noise far more agreeable than that of cars). There's a market under the rails, fruit vegtables and other foodstuffs at daytime, sm…

I will never understand the attraction of suburbs

Low taxes. Lower cost of living. Privacy of a detached house. The lack of 'city' noise. Letting my kids play in the yard, on sidewalks. Letting my kids tear around the cul-de-sac.

I've lived in the country, I've lived in the city, I've lived in the 'burbs. I prefer the latter, now.

Maybe it's just me. I live in a smaller town, my commute is a five minute drive. YMMV.

Re: The Great Cul-De-Sac Problem And How To Alleviate It.

#25
post #20

Some problems with this argument: For overhead maps 1-4, couldn't you just simply walk over on foot?

It depends. There may be fences and other obstacles in the way and it may involve trespassing. I sometimes find pedestrian-friendly paths cut through and sometimes not.

Re: The Great Cul-De-Sac Problem And How To Alleviate It.

#26
post #11

He fails to understand the main reason that home developers want to build neighborhoods with lots of cul-de-sacs: Homes on cul-de-sacs sell for more money. The more of these you can squeeze into a given neighborhood, the more money you'll make off the development.

I very much doubt it is the main reason.

I'll bet most developers do it for the money, no?

Re: The Great Cul-De-Sac Problem And How To Alleviate It.

#27
post #11

He fails to understand the main reason that home developers want to build neighborhoods with lots of cul-de-sacs: Homes on cul-de-sacs sell for more money. The more of these you can squeeze into a given neighborhood, the more money you'll make off the development.

>Homes on cul-de-sacs sell for more money. //

Presumably if the market is working properly this means that more people want to buy these homes and/or value these homes more highly than others. That is, people want to live on cul-de-sacs.

Re: The Great Cul-De-Sac Problem And How To Alleviate It.

#29
post #11

He fails to understand the main reason that home developers want to build neighborhoods with lots of cul-de-sacs: Homes on cul-de-sacs sell for more money. The more of these you can squeeze into a given neighborhood, the more money you'll make off the development.

Also it uses less road, which means more space for homes.
Post reply on HN