Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: All desktop software calculators are wrong, so I had to build my own

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 169 posts

Re: Show HN: All desktop software calculators are wrong, so I had to build my own

#11
> On a pocket calculator, you have one keyboard layout, and you simply ignore the keys you don't use. Has this ever been a problem?

Yes. There's a reason they sell basic stand-alone calculators, too, and it's not just price. There's a reason the ones for various tasks don't all look the same or have the same keys (a typical office desktop calculator is usually very basic, for instance). I'd bet money most calculators that exist are the fairly basic variety, not a fancy scientific calculator or whatever. Exclude the ones that were only ever used in school and never anywhere else and I bet it's an absolute landslide in favor of simple calculators. People are confused by the extra buttons, and don't want them.

[EDIT] Not to shit on this calculator, mind you, but this is another specialized one that won't be for everyone, not a universal solution.

Re: Show HN: All desktop software calculators are wrong, so I had to build my own

#12
post #3
post #2

https://chachatelier.fr/chalk/article/chalk.html

Unfortunately the link is unreadable on mobile due to the sidebar taking all the space.

Quickfix : I have added a button to hide the TOC. Not sure if it fits mobile screens anyway.

Re: Show HN: All desktop software calculators are wrong, so I had to build my own

#13
post #11

> On a pocket calculator, you have one keyboard layout, and you simply ignore the keys you don't use. Has this ever been a problem? Yes. There's a reason they sell basic stand-alone calculators, too, and it's not just price. There's a reason the ones for various tasks don't all look the same or have the same keys (a typical office desktop calculator is usually very basic, for instance). I'd bet money most calculators…

We will somewhat disagree, partly because I can't help using calculators as a scientist, so my opinion is particularly biased. However, I don't like the trend to hide everything that looks technical. On the long run, letting people play with advanced features (that won't break things) is a win-win.

Re: Show HN: All desktop software calculators are wrong, so I had to build my own

#14
This seems like it’s not a “for everyone” calculator, and built in OS calculators are always going to go “simple desktop calculator” design as that’s what the vast majority of people want or need.

That said I just type equations into spotlight - it doesn’t handle user defined functions, graph results, or anything, but it has a reasonably full suite of the standard arithmetic functions and operators

Re: Show HN: All desktop software calculators are wrong, so I had to build my own

#17
post #14

This seems like it’s not a “for everyone” calculator, and built in OS calculators are always going to go “simple desktop calculator” design as that’s what the vast majority of people want or need. That said I just type equations into spotlight - it doesn’t handle user defined functions, graph results, or anything, but it has a reasonably full suite of the standard arithmetic functions and operators

You know what ? I was not even aware that it would work ! (Am I the only one to discover that just now ? I am not using Spotlight very often)

It's kind of cool, but I can still find many grievances about the way it's done :-)

Re: Show HN: All desktop software calculators are wrong, so I had to build my own

#19
post #14

This seems like it’s not a “for everyone” calculator, and built in OS calculators are always going to go “simple desktop calculator” design as that’s what the vast majority of people want or need. That said I just type equations into spotlight - it doesn’t handle user defined functions, graph results, or anything, but it has a reasonably full suite of the standard arithmetic functions and operators

You know what ? I was not even aware that it would work ! (Am I the only one to discover that just now ? I am not using Spotlight very often) It's kind of cool, but I can still find many grievances about the way it's done :-)

I’m sure it’s not ideal, but for my purposes cmd-space (random math) is generally sufficient. But I’m also not a mathematician so I do maths with numbers and not letters :)

Re: Show HN: All desktop software calculators are wrong, so I had to build my own

#20
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately the link is unreadable on mobile due to the sidebar taking all the space.

Quickfix : I have added a button to hide the TOC. Not sure if it fits mobile screens anyway.

Body text remains at its original width when ToC is hidden, remaining unreadable at like 10% of screen width (with a lot of blank space).

Probably better quick fix: have ToC initialize as hidden on page load

Post reply on HN