Live data from Hacker News

To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

sampurtill.com

21–30 of 44 posts

Re: To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

#21

you get the satisfaction of knowing you aren’t a complete tool bag every time you wake up in the morning. whilst everyone reading your blog has the exact opposite impression...

Yep. This is too bad, because he makes a few good points amidst the train wreck comments like this.

Re: To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

#23

This guy is really ignorant. It's the same mentality that thinks the valley is impervious to bubbles and inflation. What? Really, "you get the satisfaction of knowing you aren’t a complete tool bag every time you wake up in the morning."... They may have lost their jobs, but you lose at life.

Schadenfreude is completely inappropriate. You were what, 12 when the dot-com shit hit the fan?

Go figure: 19 yr old php/python/actionscript hero at younoodle

Re: To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

#24

The shift key really doesn't take that long to depress, I'm not sure how not using saves you time. I had the same realization, that I had better job security at a startup, when I revisited some people I left at uni doing postdocs.

Job security for postdocs? I've never heard of a postdoc losing their job.

Sure, you might be only funded for a year at a time, but at least the money runs out on a predetermined date rather than unexpectedly one Friday.

Maybe my experiences are just limited, though.

Re: To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

#25

This guy is really ignorant. It's the same mentality that thinks the valley is impervious to bubbles and inflation. What? Really, "you get the satisfaction of knowing you aren’t a complete tool bag every time you wake up in the morning."... They may have lost their jobs, but you lose at life.

Wow Sam is getting crucified - this is even worse than when something about Co2scats makes it on Hacker News.

Here are my thoughts:

-I don't think I've ever heard of investment banking careers described as safe. When there's no deal flow, investment bankers are the first to go. If jobs could have finance betas (not software/website betas), investment banker would be around a 3.0 or higher, an accountant would be around a ~1.0, a nurse would be a 0.50 and a mailman would be a 0.25 (people have no idea how hard it is to get fired or laid off from a government job - reassignment is your friend).

-Market volatility, like a recession or oil prices affects nearly everyone directly or indirectly.

-You can "network" at any job, but I agree that it's probably easier to make friends faster at a startup due to the nature of the business. There's certainly myriad counterexamples, however.

-The tool bag line just made me laugh.

-Anecdotally, I think he's right about having a broader based skill set. Having had over 30 jobs (not a typo, I've worked since age 12) I've never picked up more useful skills in a shorter period than while at a startup. This could obviously vary.

-If you absolutely need to raise money as a startup, I think you're in one of the worst situations as capital is already drying up and people/institutions are becoming risk averse. Not good for startups.

-If you don't need to raise money and have enough savings/revenue to last for a year or two, I'm not sure if you're any better or worse off than anyone else. I'd like to hear what everyone else thinks on this.

-If you're young, without a family, sans serious medical conditions and geographically apathetic I'd argue you're better off working at an interesting startup for very cheap (stipend & equity & food & rent?) than you are taking a way-below market-compensation desk job. Why? Upside.

The lack of capitalization within the post and ping pong rub-in certainly doesn't help the cause, but I'm sure Sam has already figured that out. At least he inspired some interesting conversation; I've really enjoyed this thread.

Edit: Andr had some of the same points I did and posted before me. We've obviously both had a lot of exposure to the fun filled monkey business of finance.

Re: To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

#26

This guy is really ignorant. It's the same mentality that thinks the valley is impervious to bubbles and inflation. What? Really, "you get the satisfaction of knowing you aren’t a complete tool bag every time you wake up in the morning."... They may have lost their jobs, but you lose at life.

Just to be fair, however, he's young. I think most of us have been there. We've taken the path less trodden (self employment, working at a startup, etc.) and we've had doubts. In order to counteract those doubts, we need to act as if the "other way" is stupid, that we're better, and that we're doing the right thing.

I think that's what this guy is doing. He's young, he's confident (to a point), but he lacks the wisdom and ability to reflect that comes with age.

So while it's easy to call him "ignorant", a "douche bag", or whatever - he's not willingly being any of those things. He's young, cocky, and exuberant - like most of us were.

(Of course, when /we/ were acting the same way, we were probably getting called out the same way too.. so this process might actually be necessary to develop that wisdom ;-))

Re: To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

#27

The shift key really doesn't take that long to depress, I'm not sure how not using saves you time. I had the same realization, that I had better job security at a startup, when I revisited some people I left at uni doing postdocs.

I could understand if you just wanted to write some thoughts down as quickly as possible (hi AIM), but normally those are converted in to rough drafts and then in to finalized copy.

Re: To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

#29

This guy is really ignorant. It's the same mentality that thinks the valley is impervious to bubbles and inflation. What? Really, "you get the satisfaction of knowing you aren’t a complete tool bag every time you wake up in the morning."... They may have lost their jobs, but you lose at life.

In this case can Sam be forgiven being young and naive? So far it seems he has only experienced lifes "ups" and is surrounded by people who have yet to fail (in any significant way) with ego/attitude to match that such lack of hubris brings, hence the mentality.

Re: To all those guys who took the conservative banking jobs

#30
post #14

I didn't sit back, and chuckle when I saw 20,000 people potentially lose their jobs. Even if you don't like Wall Street, you don't want to see that many people looking for work all of a sudden.

Agreed. They have families and kids and rent. When half your friends are living and working in NYC...this has been a really rough week.
Post reply on HN