Live data from Hacker News

AI Model Detects Mental Disorders Based on Web Posts

home.dartmouth.edu

41–50 of 74 posts

Re: AI Model Detects Mental Disorders Based on Web Posts

#41

I'd say very little good can come from this. What would be an example of an "appropriate" use of this technology? Basically where it could excel is giving probabilistic prediction of "mental disorders" across a high volume of users. What is a good thing you would do with that? Advertising to suggest someone to get help, maybe?

> What would be an example of an "appropriate" use of this technology?

Well, investigative officers concerned for the well-being of the individual and the potential for self harm or danger to others could attempt to help them with a taser or a shotgun.

Or, if you are a liberal you could have an algorithmic silo-ing of their posts? That way it would be demonstrably not a prejudiced censorship but something that could be investigated later if the right channels are followed.

It could be coupled with the software that detects whether people are homosexual or conservative based on their physiognomy.

Re: AI Model Detects Mental Disorders Based on Web Posts

#42
post #3

Witty. But those claims must feel a bit insulting to people who actually study mental disorders, chemical imbalances etc.

"chemical imbalances", is that a thing?

So basically this was a theory that came out around when LSD was discovered to impact the serotonin system.

It never really panned out but psychiatrists continue to use it. They will say it’s like a metaphor to get people to accept taking medications.

When I was confronted w diagnosis of Biploar / schizoaffective and having suicidal depression and psychotic mania — over a decade ago, I basically landed at… the tribe of psychiatry calls the dance I’m doing a certain thing, but their solutions are really not that sound and we can do better.

So, I didn’t continue to ignore what was going on, but I went on a personal research mission and took on my diagnosis as a dharma, not a dogma.

Ultimately I was able to address the underlying trauma, relationship patterns and language patterns that lead to all of those things, and now lead a life filled with joy, deep calm, gratitude and possibility, with no medications — despite what the standford psychiatrists said was possible.

Psychedelics helped as well, and I went on to run an underground clinic in NYC for a few years before they were mainstream; I developed a Breathwork practice that helped as well (without drugs) BioMythic.com, and founded a non-profit w funding from Doc Bronners to legalize access to psychedelic medicines.

Also realized the path I was on was really about developing a capacity for deep presence and leadership as founders from Unicorn startups began showing up at my door so to speak to help them master their inner landscapes so they could articulate their bigger visions.

I’ve had the honor to be the personal coach on relationship, spirituality, mental wellness and leadership for some of the biggest names in tech.

And for me, it was ultimately a discovery that this “thing” that was causing me pain and I was told I needed to medicate away, was actually my greatest gift. And now it’s allowed me to run a multi six figure coaching business for a few hours of client calls a week, while touring around the country in MajikBus.co

Anyhow, long rant, but I found other peoples stories really helpful when I was finding my way outside the main stream!

Re: AI Model Detects Mental Disorders Based on Web Posts

#44
post #41

I'd say very little good can come from this. What would be an example of an "appropriate" use of this technology? Basically where it could excel is giving probabilistic prediction of "mental disorders" across a high volume of users. What is a good thing you would do with that? Advertising to suggest someone to get help, maybe?

> What would be an example of an "appropriate" use of this technology? Well, investigative officers concerned for the well-being of the individual and the potential for self harm or danger to others could attempt to help them with a taser or a shotgun. Or, if you are a liberal you could have an algorithmic silo-ing of their posts? That way it would be demonstrably not a prejudiced censorship but something that could…

Also, it could usefully be used to identify people for treatment as was done in the old USSR: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2800147/

Re: AI Model Detects Mental Disorders Based on Web Posts

#45

I would assume that someone will come up with a phone app to fix text so it triggers no filters. SaneSpeak fixes your communications to analyze as sane, honest, and confident. Simple sliders allow you to project the personality you want your audience's AI to pick up. Chose proven presets and watch those sales and promotions roll in.

This would work great as an AR overlay, auto-suggesting one's next sentence in a conversation, so that it sounds more sane and confident.

With enough training and refinement, we might be able to get the % of original untweaked human utterances down to single digits.

> Maria's public Wishlist indicates she recently purchased those shoes. Her public watchlist indicates she watches Severance on Apple TV. A main character, Helly, wears similar-looking shoes. Maria has used the word "fab" to describe items of clothing in 3.6% of her Instagram posts. Next, comment to Maria that her "fab shoes" remind you of the ones you saw Helly wear on Severance?

Re: AI Model Detects Mental Disorders Based on Web Posts

#48

I'd say very little good can come from this. What would be an example of an "appropriate" use of this technology? Basically where it could excel is giving probabilistic prediction of "mental disorders" across a high volume of users. What is a good thing you would do with that? Advertising to suggest someone to get help, maybe?

Could there be some public health benefits? Could the data help governments decide where to spend money and evaluate if the money spent has had any effect?

Re: AI Model Detects Mental Disorders Based on Web Posts

#49

I'd say very little good can come from this. What would be an example of an "appropriate" use of this technology? Basically where it could excel is giving probabilistic prediction of "mental disorders" across a high volume of users. What is a good thing you would do with that? Advertising to suggest someone to get help, maybe?

Could there be some public health benefits? Could the data help governments decide where to spend money and evaluate if the money spent has had any effect?

if the concern is abuse, i wouldn’t give it to gov

Re: AI Model Detects Mental Disorders Based on Web Posts

#50
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could there be some public health benefits? Could the data help governments decide where to spend money and evaluate if the money spent has had any effect?

if the concern is abuse, i wouldn’t give it to gov

Right, because it's better to trust that analysis to FaceBook. Why they could even pop-up something suggesting you seek help.
Post reply on HN