Live data from Hacker News

Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

github.com

31–40 of 246 posts

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#31

How does this work on a high level? If the server never sends the content, how can a client-side extension get it? Do most website just hide this on the frontend?

Usually #3. Or corrupting whatever the site uses to run its “5 free articles per month” counter.

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#32

How does this work on a high level? If the server never sends the content, how can a client-side extension get it? Do most website just hide this on the frontend?

Lot of different tricks. One example: just by using a Google Bot user agent some websites will let you access the full content. Sometimes working with some cookies, blocking some particular 3rd party JavaScript libs, some other are more complicated.

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#33
post #6

An article worth reading is worth buying.

Amen. Good news is expensive. It takes a lots a lot of resources and trained professional's hours to make a well researched story. High quality investigative news outfits have real, positive impact on society. They root out corruption and help bring injustices to light.

I figure most people on this site can afford to subscribe to a news source or two and probably should.

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#34
Do people generally feel like digital goods should be free? Seems like people are always trying to rationalize bypassing paywalls, pirating games and using emulators, torrenting movies, etc.

It’s very ironic that this is a tech forum, much of which is software and this view is prevalent among some here

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#35

How does this work on a high level? If the server never sends the content, how can a client-side extension get it? Do most website just hide this on the frontend?

Perusing this file here - https://github.com/iamadamdev/bypass-paywalls-chrome/blob/ma...

It removes the popup elements that cover the page and other little tricks.

The common key thing across all of them, though - the server is sending the content, and then a little JS payload that creates the popup asking you to pay.

It's not a particularly good way of protecting the content of the article, for obvious reasons.

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#36
post #6

An article worth reading is worth buying.

How am I supposed to know beforehand if an article is worth reading?

I ran into a lot of articles on HN which are behind a pay wall (I use this extension), but were not deeply interesting, therefore I left after one or two paragraphs. I can't imagine how much money I would've spent on nothing if I'd pay for every article I click on.

Also, I believe the news outlets have a similar problem like video stream providers: too much fragmentation. When I'm forced to subscribe to prime for a specific movie, then to netflix for another movie, then to disney for ANOTHER movie, I'll eventually end up just pirating them all.

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#37

PSA: Newspapers educate the public, and their services are essential for the functioning of our democracies. The best newspapers fund their operations through subscriptions, so please help society become well-informed by subscribing to your favorite newspapers.

We need a better solution than subscribing to a monolithic news source. Specially when they make it super hard to unsubscribe cough NYT cough.

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#38
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am deeply suspicious of "shoulds" on other people. Maybe normal human beings should pay enough that newspapers can survive.

What if they don't? I agree in principle, but I struggle to see what business model can allow newspapers to survive in the digital era.

NYTimes stock has gone up 200% over the last 5 years. I think they're doing fine.

Re: Bypass Paywalls: a browser extension to help bypass paywalls for selected sites

#40

PSA: Newspapers educate the public, and their services are essential for the functioning of our democracies. The best newspapers fund their operations through subscriptions, so please help society become well-informed by subscribing to your favorite newspapers.

I pay for NYT, but I can't subscribe to the paper of every article I want to read. I need some kind of group subscription for it to be feasible.
Post reply on HN