Live data from Hacker News

Map of Surnames in Europe

surnamemap.eu

171–180 of 197 posts

Re: Map of Surnames in Europe

#171

For the names I looked up in the UK, this might as well have been a map of population centres. Almost every surname was focused in London, Birmingham and Manchester. It's to be expected, I suppose, but not very informative.

First thing I did was typing up my French originating surname; big agglomerate right around Paris, then Normandy (where my ancestors came from).

Re: Map of Surnames in Europe

#172
post #131
post #80

This website is overloaded with adds. It almost feels like a scam. Based on the fact that almost all other comments are not talking about it, I guess at least one of the following hypotheses is true (if not all of them): - most people here use an efficient addblocker - The website changed since its first appearance on the first page (maximize revenue?) - some comments are sponsored - on mobile it feels overwhelming b…

> overloaded ? got curious enough to turn off my adblocker: i was presented with TWO ads on desktop i think you overloaded the term overloaded. though they are huge on mobile.. and appear to be subleased or something. also there appears to be another ad element below the "(C)" line on mobile which is missing on desktop

There also seems to be a modal ad on hover out. Hadn't seen that used before for ads.

Re: Map of Surnames in Europe

#173
post #120
post #80

This website is overloaded with adds. It almost feels like a scam. Based on the fact that almost all other comments are not talking about it, I guess at least one of the following hypotheses is true (if not all of them): - most people here use an efficient addblocker - The website changed since its first appearance on the first page (maximize revenue?) - some comments are sponsored - on mobile it feels overwhelming b…

I flagged this submission and recommend this post be deleted and the submitter penalized.

Is there a rule about not posting submissions with ads? If so, most news sites would likely be heavily penalized.

In other words, what rules exactly do you think this post violated, and why should the submitter be penalized? For posting a site with ads?

Re: Map of Surnames in Europe

#174

Data is not clean, I doubt people have the surname "Computer" or "Bahnhof" (train station) in Germany

Also search for City names which yields very suspicious results: https://www.kartezumnamen.eu/en/index.php?sur=Hamburg&s=Sear... https://www.kartezumnamen.eu/en/index.php?sur=Berlin&s=Searc... https://www.kartezumnamen.eu/en/index.php?sur=M%FCnchen&s=Se... I don't think there are that many people called like cities and also they don't all live in those cities.

Data set is broken... he just want to earn some HN traffic and ads money

Re: Map of Surnames in Europe

#175
post #166
post #142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm glad it worked out for you. It is a funny story, though, so don't be mad at me for chuckling a little bit. (I guess the guests at your wedding did so, too.) A friend of my mother's has to twin sons who married two women who had not only the same first name but also worked at the same company. Both ladies took their husbands' names, so they both had the same names. I imagine it must have been both funny and confus…

our ERP software used the name as a primary key for employees As someone with a common first name and common surname, this drives me bananas. I still get emails from my graduate university to email: first.last@uni.edu meant for some undergraduate in a sea of 50k students, and have to reply that I've had that email for 20 years and they have the wrong person with a very common name.

I have to admit I found the very concept of using a value that could change as a primary repulsive from an aesthetic point of view. It's just bad database design.

Still, I feel for you. My primary concern, though, was that it made life more complicated for me. But email adresses were separate from ERP user names, and we did not have two employees with the same name, so first.last@company.com was good enough for our purposes.

Re: Map of Surnames in Europe

#176
post #60

Vaguely related amusing bit of trivia: the word for smith or blacksmith is one of the most common names about everywhere: Smith (England), Schmidt (Germany), Smit/Smet (Belgium, Netherlands), Fabre/Favre/Lefèvre/Lefèbvre (France), Ferrari/Fabri (Italy), Ferrero/Herrero (Spain), Ferreiro (Portugal), Kowalski (Poland), Haddad (Morocco), Demirci (Turkey), Demirdjian (Armenia), Gof/Goff/Le Goff (Brittany, Wales), Gowan/G…

Armenian is Darbinian/Tarpinian (Demirjian is the Turkish-Armenian hybrid form). There's also related Nalbandian (farrier / horseshoe blacksmith).

BTW, the theory I've heard is that this surname prevails due to survivorship bias, in countries that were constantly at war and the male population was being decimated, the smiths had to stay back home manufacturing weapons (same logic applies for "miller" and "tailor" and "mayor", all very common last names in large parts of Europe).

Re: Map of Surnames in Europe

#178
post #110

Where does it obtain data in countries without registries (such as France)?

doesn't France conduct census? I'm pretty sure I had to get registered when I reached the majority age. And, according to other comments, the website used phone books (which existed in France)

When I moved there, I didn't have to, or could, notify anyone I was living there.

Re: Map of Surnames in Europe

#180
post #60

Vaguely related amusing bit of trivia: the word for smith or blacksmith is one of the most common names about everywhere: Smith (England), Schmidt (Germany), Smit/Smet (Belgium, Netherlands), Fabre/Favre/Lefèvre/Lefèbvre (France), Ferrari/Fabri (Italy), Ferrero/Herrero (Spain), Ferreiro (Portugal), Kowalski (Poland), Haddad (Morocco), Demirci (Turkey), Demirdjian (Armenia), Gof/Goff/Le Goff (Brittany, Wales), Gowan/G…

To add to this bit of trivia. In Sweden this was never a thing where your job became your surname. If you go to a cemetery you'll sometimes see the occupation on the gravestone though, especially on older graves and if it was a more higher class job.

Admittedly it seems less common, but... there certainly are some Smeds in Sweden (and the rest of Scandinavia). The names are not ALL sons/sens and geographic features... https://forebears.io/surnames/smed
Post reply on HN