Live data from Hacker News

10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

torrentfreak.com

41–50 of 80 posts

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#41

The successor, mega.nz, is genuinely a great service. I know doctors who use it for (legally) sending patient scans, with the key sent OOB, for example. It has a nice linux CLI, mega-cmd, and is intelligently made, cheap, and widely available.

It also has by far the most sophisticated settings for any cloud drive I've seen so far

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#42

The successor, mega.nz, is genuinely a great service. I know doctors who use it for (legally) sending patient scans, with the key sent OOB, for example. It has a nice linux CLI, mega-cmd, and is intelligently made, cheap, and widely available.

I don’t understand why anyone would trust MEGA when there are other good storage options without the baggage.

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#43
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I never really understood how MEGA is any better. Sure, personal files are encrypted, and thus it's hard to detect pirated files that I upload for myself. But a lot of piracy happens with publicly downloadable files, which MEGA can definitely decrypt and search for copyright violations. I'll be honest -- I've used both MEGA and Megaupload for piracy, and MEGA makes it easier.

How can MEGA decrypt those "publicly shared" files to scan them? Do you think they should scan whole internet for such file links?

I think only a zealot or MPAA/RIAA lawyer is blinded enough to see that as an actual answer to your question :)

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#44

I refuse to invest any time, energy, or money in MEGA. The reason? The brand has reputation issues. They could've dropped `Mega` from the service's name, but determined researchers would find out it's by the MegaUpload crowd and blow the whistle on that, so there's no recourse from the raids, just tarnished reputation, encrypted files or not.

It doesn't really unless you welcome police overreach and MPAA/RIAA bullies. Fight the power and shit.

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#45

I don't understand why we taxpayers decide to pool our money to pay for a staff of employees to ensure that we can't have free music and movies. I would prefer free music and movies over more federal payroll. It's like we all pitched in to ensure Kim Kardashian can have more money.

100% this. There was a copyism movement a while back that basically believed humans should have the right to copy and share as they like.

Let's not pretend that free sharing leads to starving musicians. All but a very few are already starving now, and our culture is centralized into a bland nothingness because of it.

In a free to share world, value for value wins. Artists have experimented with donation requested but otherwise free music and won.

In this model there's also no need for distribution or streaming middleman.

And no need for Fed coffers and intervention.

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, MEGA is amazing. Unlike Megaupload, I have only used MEGA for personal use and not pirated content download. I think MEGA being fully encrypted was their answer to them being targeted for hosting any illegal content (with MEGA, they were hosting encrypted files, which they don't have access to themselves because the encryption key remains with the client). Did it take off as the replacement for pirated content s…

I never really understood how MEGA is any better. Sure, personal files are encrypted, and thus it's hard to detect pirated files that I upload for myself. But a lot of piracy happens with publicly downloadable files, which MEGA can definitely decrypt and search for copyright violations. I'll be honest -- I've used both MEGA and Megaupload for piracy, and MEGA makes it easier.

> But a lot of piracy happens with publicly downloadable files, which MEGA can definitely decrypt and search for copyright violations.

This is straight up wrong. Mega cannot decrypt files and search for copyright files just like that. They need to have the key for that. I have shared a lot of copyrighted stuff on mega and the links are still available publicly but in closed forums( still active ). mega would've taken it down a long time back if they knew what was in it. They can only take down files when corpos notify them with the base links to the file. If they don't it stays up.

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#47

I don't understand why we taxpayers decide to pool our money to pay for a staff of employees to ensure that we can't have free music and movies. I would prefer free music and movies over more federal payroll. It's like we all pitched in to ensure Kim Kardashian can have more money.

I like free food, money, and objects.

Lol, from Zappa's Absolutely Free

> FREE IS WHEN YOU DON'T HAVE TO PAY FOR NOTHING OR DO NOTHING WE WANT TO BE FREE FREE AS THE WIND

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#48
post #18
post #9

The peak for warez communities was right around 2006. I distinctly remember how popular those forums and other sites were. There were ridiculous amounts of pirated software and media being shared, and most of that content was in fact hosted on Megaupload or RapidShare. If you knew people (from IRC) you could get invited to scene torrent sites which was a much more efficient way of getting what you want. I mean, every…

What I miss the most about this "peak warez" period (and most of the mid to late 00s, basically) is the huge amount of blogs uploading rare old music. During this sweet period I was able to get a lot of very rare music from all over the world (as a bouns, you could in practice guarantee that it was virus-free since unlike actual warez these files weren't executable. Yes, I know that dedicated attackers can still find…

Hitting a college campus with a legitimately high speed OC level connection, a lax-internal network for connected machines, meant Napster and game servers went nuts on my campus turn of the 2000.

I still have a folder of miscellaneous files obtained from Napster by simply searching "remix" every few days. Yes, the quality is very hit or miss, but many I've never come across again, even in years of clubbing, videos online, etc. For example, this wound up in my collection:

https://www.discogs.com/Stina-Nordenstam-People-Are-Strange/...

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#49
post #3

I don't remember any direct pirate activity from megaupload.

Huh? You were using megaupload for legitimate reasons? I would counter that I don't recall any instance of using it for non illegal downloads.

There was reports after the raids of people losing backup data. Yes, people used a cyberlocker service for backup.

Re: 10 years ago the Feds shut down Megaupload

#50

I don't understand why we taxpayers decide to pool our money to pay for a staff of employees to ensure that we can't have free music and movies. I would prefer free music and movies over more federal payroll. It's like we all pitched in to ensure Kim Kardashian can have more money.

Would you be okay if large for profit companies didn’t have to abide by open source licenses? What’s the incentive to make movies or music just to be given away for free? Would you work for free?

> Would you be okay if large for profit companies didn’t have to abide by open source licenses?

Yes. I believe in the MIT licensing model.

> What’s the incentive to make movies or music just to be given away for free?

Firstly, almost all the money made from movies/music is not made by the artists who created. It goes to the shareholders of large corporations. Secondly, I believe in the hacker ethic of free information online. All media/information/etc online should be free. In the physical, making copies of anything costs time and money. Whereas copying digital items is a click of a mouse. Thirdly, artists can still make money via their fans. If fans like their stuff, those who can afford it will pay.

> Would you work for free?

Nobody is. But then again, why pay someone for something they didn't create. Licensing doesn't exist to protect artists. It exists to protect large corporations.

Post reply on HN