Live data from Hacker News

Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

apnews.com

21–30 of 103 posts

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#21

Playing armchair general here, but I wonder what's the playbook if Russia decides to conduct a nuclear weapon "experiment".

>Playing armchair general here, but I wonder what's the playbook if Russia decides to conduct a nuclear weapon "experiment".

Any launch regardless of trajectory will be considered act of war against the world. There will be no warning shots here.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#22

The days of mutually assured destruction is actually over. In the time needed for the ICBMs to reach targets on another continent is enough time to intercept those missiles. Obviously neighbours like Finland and Ukraine on the otherhand are problematic. I hope the best for them. Many missile defense systems have been worked on, sattelites with high powered lasers, planes with high powered lasers, intercepting missile…

Satellites with high powered lasers are a fantasy that don't exist right now.

The converted Boeing 747 airborne laser was a colossal failure and would have only been able to target a missile nearby in its boost/launch phase. It's now dismantled.

You think you can send fighters to gun down an icbm MIRV in its re-entry phase? Seriously?

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#24
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is more serious than you think. Putin thought that, by now, he'll be already controlling the capital and setting a new puppet government. He is clearly losing the war (he was looking for quick toppling of the government). Putin is in a very bad situation right now. And having his nuclear "deterrents" in high-readiness doesn't help.

Not only that. European countries are keen on giving Kiyv more weapons [0], which is what Putin has been warning against. [0] https://twitter.com/Bundeskanzler/status/1497632817450266632

But somewhere you'll have to draw the line when dealing with a dictator on nukes or he won't stop using that card ever.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#25
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the past we took such warnings seriously. I think that was wise.

In the past we saw how decades of nuclear tension passed by without a single bomb dropping. I don't think anyone has a real appetite for nuclear war.

Playing the game of chicken enough times will lead to a bad outcome.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#26

Playing armchair general here, but I wonder what's the playbook if Russia decides to conduct a nuclear weapon "experiment".

Launching a missile to explode over the ocean to show resolve to use nukes. Next, launching a missile to explode over some Alaskan waste, if the previous step doesn't induce NATO to start the negotiations. Something like that.

That would trigger an overwhelming response.

Nuclear weapons create huge EMP bursts which disrupt communications. One popular type of theoretical first strike is to detonate one or two missiles in the atmosphere to cause confusion, then follow up with the main salvos while peoples' main sensors and communications are blind.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#27

Playing armchair general here, but I wonder what's the playbook if Russia decides to conduct a nuclear weapon "experiment".

>Playing armchair general here, but I wonder what's the playbook if Russia decides to conduct a nuclear weapon "experiment". Any launch regardless of trajectory will be considered act of war against the world. There will be no warning shots here.

That's not true.

There are more options available to US than just "fire all the missiles".

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#28
post #11

Putin is full of hot air. I believe with how this is going, one of his advisors or generals will kill him before allowing him to actually fire nukes and initiate MAD. These people might be ok letting him play war in the Ukraine but inviting annihilation from the rest of the world? I'm not so sure. But then again, it doesn't seem like there's a lot of rational behavior coming out of Putin's Russia.

I fear that anyone inside Russia, that could be in a position to topple him has been silenced long ago. At this point, he is trenched in like Stalin.

Every puppet has his or her limit though.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#29
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Playing armchair general here, but I wonder what's the playbook if Russia decides to conduct a nuclear weapon "experiment". Any launch regardless of trajectory will be considered act of war against the world. There will be no warning shots here.

That's not true. There are more options available to US than just "fire all the missiles".

>There are more options available to US than just "fire all the missiles".

I mean any launch by Russia will be declaration of war on everyone.

I don't know the effectiveness of stopping these nukes with missile defense. I suspect the USA has multiple plans that they expect to be effective.

Post reply on HN