Live data from Hacker News

One in three young people say they felt happier during lockdown

cam.ac.uk

11–20 of 130 posts

Re: One in three young people say they felt happier during lockdown

#11

> In fact, an almost identical number of students fell into each of the three categories: their mental wellbeing had improved; there had been no change; or they had experienced a deterioration to their wellbeing. This feels like a red flag on the conclusions. How does this compare to a normal time period? I wouldn’t be surprised if the random ups and downs of growing up normally resulted in a distribution where 1/3 o…

My take is that this is a counterpoint to the dominant media narrative that covid and lockdowns have been detrimental to the mental heath of nearly every child, usually based on anecdata. So even if these results _aren't_ different from a normal year, that's still meaningful.

I think this is the crux of their conclusions too:

> While the pandemic has undoubtedly had negative consequences for many, it is important to keep in mind that this is not the case for all children and young people.

Re: One in three young people say they felt happier during lockdown

#13

> In fact, an almost identical number of students fell into each of the three categories: their mental wellbeing had improved; there had been no change; or they had experienced a deterioration to their wellbeing. This feels like a red flag on the conclusions. How does this compare to a normal time period? I wouldn’t be surprised if the random ups and downs of growing up normally resulted in a distribution where 1/3 o…

Breaking news: half of people happier than average!

Re: One in three young people say they felt happier during lockdown

#14
post #2

Of course. As students (born in the internet+smartphone era) they were primed all their life to feel freer in asocial cocooning

> As students (born in the internet+smartphone era) they were primed all their life to feel freer in asocial cocooning

Don't know what kind of students you're thinking about - I can't imagine anyone more intensely social than a group of freshers?

Re: One in three young people say they felt happier during lockdown

#16

The pandemic started towards the end of my masters and beyond the initial “oh shit” moment, I actually found it way better than I expected because for the first time in my life it was not weird for me to just stay at home, enjoy my own company and reduce socializing by a factor of 5 or more. Now when I actually have to interact with people it’s in a low enough volume that it’s enjoyable and not the crapshoot it used…

I can relate. During my studies I often felt like I ought to make the most of having people around. So much is made of the opportunity to meet people at uni, it feels odd to waste it. With a lockdown I think I'd be just fine at home or in a student hall, putting the most into studying.

Having just started an online masters, I've noticed that socialization can bias strongly towards "Purposeful" socialization e.g. A slack channel for discussing the class/assignments.

Compared to my undergrad there were many times I think I just sat around drinking/watching movies because there was a social group doing it. I wonder if the lack of purpose in such activities grinds on students over time.

Re: One in three young people say they felt happier during lockdown

#17
Ugh... 'happier' is a strong conclusion.If I had to guess the actual effect probably is something along the lines of people having more time for themselves, taking a break from society, and realizing they're stressed for no reason most of the time.

This is not to say that the lockdown made anybody happier.I'm willing to bet the causal factor is the fact that people experienced a little bit of isolation, "me-time", took a break from the daily noise(especially the majority of people who spend too much time on social media).

I want to see the more in-depth numbers: how many of those who reportedly stated that they felt happier during lockdown were using social media and/or were 'over-socializing' to the point that their own happiness was tied to other people's expectations?

Re: One in three young people say they felt happier during lockdown

#19
So 1 in 3 felt happier, 1 in 3 felt more depressed, and the remaining 1 in 3 felt no major change.

Sounds pretty much like a normal (gaussian) distribution, or basically a non-story. Guessing if they measured satisfaction on a scale, the majority were clustered near the "no major change" camp, as with any gaussian curve. As we already know, it turns out humans can adapt to things.

By phrasing the headline result as "1 in 3 felt happier," it creates a narrative where there likely isn't one. You imagine the 33% were this solid block of people feeling much happier. But, re: the gaussian distribution, its likely very few were at the extremes, and most were clustered towards the middle.

Textbook clickbait. It invites you to react with your emotional, anecdotal feelings about what this means to you, as if there was any interesting finding there.

Re: One in three young people say they felt happier during lockdown

#20
What a stupid claim. Based on useless self reported data.

Also their “data” is two years old:

> More than 17,000 students took part in the June/July 2020 survey, during the tail end of the first national lockdown

Think the young people might report feeling different now?

Post reply on HN