Live data from Hacker News

NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

newpipe.net

71–80 of 227 posts

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#71

NewPipe is great but it breaks quite frequently due to the use of unofficial YouTube APIs. I tried to get my girlfriend on it because she was annoyed by all the ads but it kept breaking every month. Vanced is nice but a weakness for both is that they can't support casting on a non-jailbroken device (and I suspect the issue won't be solved by jailbreaking).

I have been using it for more than a year, and I have updated it like 3-4 times. Maybe you just got unlucky?

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#72

NewPipe is great but it breaks quite frequently due to the use of unofficial YouTube APIs. I tried to get my girlfriend on it because she was annoyed by all the ads but it kept breaking every month. Vanced is nice but a weakness for both is that they can't support casting on a non-jailbroken device (and I suspect the issue won't be solved by jailbreaking).

That's Google's fault, not NewPipe's.

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#73
post #61

One of the biggest strengths of Vanced over NewPipe when i tried them both was SponsorBlock [0] Is there a similar feature available in Newpipe now? [0]: https://sponsor.ajay.app/

Not trying to make accusations but why would anyone block these segments? Isn't that how the content creator is making a living? I just skip them by hand if they go on and on or I've already seen it or whatever.

I'm not going to buy anything based on the sponsor segment, so skipping it doesn't deprive the creator of any money.

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#74
post #73
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not trying to make accusations but why would anyone block these segments? Isn't that how the content creator is making a living? I just skip them by hand if they go on and on or I've already seen it or whatever.

I'm not going to buy anything based on the sponsor segment, so skipping it doesn't deprive the creator of any money.

That's true in the short term, but sponsors don't pay for people to shill their products if nobody's watching.

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#75

I recommend https://vancedapp.com/

Yeah, last time I tried NewPipe has no login (probably obviously). I use YTB almost exclusively to watch my subscriptions. Without that it's kinda useless (I'm aware you can import a channel list somehow in NewPipe, but it's very inconvenient if you constantly sub/unsub stuff.)

Just manage your subscriptions in NewPipe. Don't give any data to Google.

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#76
post #74
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not going to buy anything based on the sponsor segment, so skipping it doesn't deprive the creator of any money.

That's true in the short term, but sponsors don't pay for people to shill their products if nobody's watching.

Of course someone is watching — the kinds of people who would never use NewPipe in the first place.

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#77
I like this app as well as this is an effective hindrance to not get sucked into the recommendations and losing time with endless amount of content youtube rates as interesting for me (and it often really is, unfortunately). Nevertheless, I like some channels and their visibilty and success depends on views, likes and interactions. If it is just about monetization, there are alternatives beyond youtube, but pure visibility and growth if the chanel isn't already established to its full potential? I'm wondering in how far I'm weakening those channels / creators when accessing their content through this tool.

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What does getting YouTube Premium add to that plan? Wouldn't it work just as well without that step?

You need YouTube Premium to be able to download videos to watch offline (plus see no ads)

All you need is Vanced or NewPipe.

Re: NewPipe: A lightweight YouTube experience for Android

#80
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

why would you ask someone why they do something and then immediately explain that you literally do the exact same thing? the only difference is you do it manually and they found a way to automate it. the reason they skip them is the exact same reason people use ad block on youtube or download movies. they don't care and it's more convenient that way.

I explained why I skipped it in some circumstances, I think I probably watch 90% of them. Or does this sponsor block thing let you choose when to skip? It didn't look like it but that would be great if so.

For the Sponsorblock browser addons you can configure them to only show you a button to skip the segments if you like. I'm not sure if that option is available in Vanced or the NewPipe Sponsorblock fork.
Post reply on HN