Live data from Hacker News

We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

martindaniel.co

31–40 of 117 posts

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#31
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually my experience is the opposite. In colder climates such as Russia, Finland I have seen room temperatures to be quite mild, above 20C for sure. However, in Italy in winter it is quite cold inside. Needless to say that thermal insulation is awful in IT.

Could it be that the outdoors being so cold increases radiation losses so you need a higher air temperature to compensate? Personally I find if it's especially cold outside, I need to put the thermostat up to compensate.

It’s because mild climates have bad insulation and when it’s 5C out moving the thermostat from 17 to 21 is a big change.

When it’s -25C out, not so much.

Japan can actually be a case study of that: detached homes on Honshu (the main island) generally have poor insulation, in winter they tend to be quite cold and spot-heated (using kotatsu and kerosene space heaters, with heavy clothing).

On Hokkaido meanwhile, good insulation (including double or triple pane windows) and central heating are common (the island has insulation regs and there are loans dedicated to properly protecting against the cold), and inside temperatures tend to be cosy. It’s a regular occurrence that Hokkaido residents catch colds when visiting tokyo in winter, because they don’t have the habit of bundling up inside.

Though when it comes to Honshu, one of the justifications for the lack of insulation is the difficulty of keeping indoors drafty and dry during the extremely wet summer, to avoid the walls outright rotting on you.

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#33
post #7
post #6

They may be saving energy, but 17.2°C average temperature indoors is freezing.

No it’s not. That’s a very normal temperature for our bedroom in the winter time. It probably depends where you’re from, in colder climates people are used to it.

That could be the temperature of my bedroom. Which I only sleep in. I also bring a warm water bottle to bed every night.

I don’t know if I live in a cold climate but people will start to complain if the temperature goes below 21C indoors.

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#34
post #10
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No it’s not. That’s a very normal temperature for our bedroom in the winter time. It probably depends where you’re from, in colder climates people are used to it.

Actually my experience is the opposite. In colder climates such as Russia, Finland I have seen room temperatures to be quite mild, above 20C for sure. However, in Italy in winter it is quite cold inside. Needless to say that thermal insulation is awful in IT.

Mine too. I'm from Michigan and my wife is from Hong Kong. In HK they don't have heating at all, and they generally keep the windows open all the time because it's so humid. It's usually pretty mild in the winter, but they have "cold snaps" where it might only be 12C; and if it's 12C outside, it's 12C inside. They just put on more clothes. So in a reversal of the stereotypes, she's usually the one wanting to turn the thermostat down, and I'm the one wanting to turn the thermostat up.

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The annual carbon budget of each person is about 3 tons per person. Thats the amount planet's biosphere can process divided by number of peoplle.

> annual carbon budget of each person is about 3 tons per person To put that stat in perspective, the average carbon emmisions per person [0]: Qatar is almost 40 tonnes pp United States, Canada, Australia is about 15 tonnes pp Switzerland, France, Italy, under 5 tonnes pp South Sudan is about 0.13 tonnes. It really puts in perspective how much wasteful carbon reduction and lifestyle changes are needed for us to have…

Remember that these figures include indirect emissions such as the ones made by the government on your behalf to maintain, for example, carbon expensive infrastructure.

The roads are a big part of that in the US. American suburban car dependency needs to die.

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#36
post #8
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's insulation but insolation can also help with saving energy ;)

I'm guessing `insolation` turns you into a clean energy source. Can't imagine it's good for the immediate surroundings though.

> Can't imagine it's good for the immediate surroundings though.

Not sure about that. Plants absolutely love insolation!

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#37
post #4

Did I miss the amortization of the CO2 emitted during the change?

To preface, I am not trying to nitpick here. I am generally curious. Is this a correct usage of amortization? https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/amortization

I don’t know, I’m not a native English speaker. I meant that: “to gradually reduce or write off the cost or value of (something, such as an asset)”

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The annual carbon budget of each person is about 3 tons per person. Thats the amount planet's biosphere can process divided by number of peoplle.

> annual carbon budget of each person is about 3 tons per person To put that stat in perspective, the average carbon emmisions per person [0]: Qatar is almost 40 tonnes pp United States, Canada, Australia is about 15 tonnes pp Switzerland, France, Italy, under 5 tonnes pp South Sudan is about 0.13 tonnes. It really puts in perspective how much wasteful carbon reduction and lifestyle changes are needed for us to have…

Thanks, do you have sources for this information? I would really like to take a look at this in more detail.

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#39
nitpicking time :D

> (assuming a 0.3g of CO2e per kWh

It's kg there, not g.

And this number is for the electricity, gas is 0.203 kg per kWh.

If you are indeed heating with electricity, in france the electricity CO2 is almost always below 100g of CO2e per kWh.

Re: We changed our roof and cut CO2 emissions

#40
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> annual carbon budget of each person is about 3 tons per person To put that stat in perspective, the average carbon emmisions per person [0]: Qatar is almost 40 tonnes pp United States, Canada, Australia is about 15 tonnes pp Switzerland, France, Italy, under 5 tonnes pp South Sudan is about 0.13 tonnes. It really puts in perspective how much wasteful carbon reduction and lifestyle changes are needed for us to have…

Thanks, do you have sources for this information? I would really like to take a look at this in more detail.

Added source in the parent comment.
Post reply on HN