Live data from Hacker News

Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

nypost.com

11–20 of 73 posts

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#12
post #8

The BLM movement and the BLM organization are different. Much the same way that Americans will all claim to be democrats but less than half will claim to be Democrats.

I don't know of any American who claims to be a democrat without also claiming to be a Democrat; the terms are synonymous with the political party in the US.

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#13
post #11
post #8

The BLM movement and the BLM organization are different. Much the same way that Americans will all claim to be democrats but less than half will claim to be Democrats.

Quoted post unavailable.

I think in this instance "democrat" is being used to mean "supporter of democracy".

I don't think you aren't an American if you aren't a supporter of democracy, per se, but I do think the principle is a fairly core tenet of what it is, or at least is supposed to be, to be "American". I would be unsurprised if other people said you were un-American for feeling this way.

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#14
post #8

The BLM movement and the BLM organization are different. Much the same way that Americans will all claim to be democrats but less than half will claim to be Democrats.

>Much the same way that Americans will all claim to be democrats

I'm not a democrat and I'm American.

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#15
post #8

The BLM movement and the BLM organization are different. Much the same way that Americans will all claim to be democrats but less than half will claim to be Democrats.

I don't know of any American who claims to be a democrat without also claiming to be a Democrat; the terms are synonymous with the political party in the US.

While the literal term isn't used the way the parent describes I believe that their comment is trying to communicate "While only half of Americans describe themselves as Democrats, most Americans would say they're "an advocate or supporter of democracy" (the definition of a democrat).

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#16
post #8

The BLM movement and the BLM organization are different. Much the same way that Americans will all claim to be democrats but less than half will claim to be Democrats.

I don't know of any American who claims to be a democrat without also claiming to be a Democrat; the terms are synonymous with the political party in the US.

Perhaps they meant: Americans will all claim to be democratic*

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#17
I can't help but feel like non-profits who name themselves after decentralized movements are often a grift. They count on people not knowing the difference and giving them money to support a cause they may or may not actually contribute to.

I should point out that this isn't universally true, the woman who set up the initial "Woman's March" event on Facebook, Teresa Shook, founded an organization of the same name, so there is some legitimacy to that org's claim there.

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#18
post #8

The BLM movement and the BLM organization are different. Much the same way that Americans will all claim to be democrats but less than half will claim to be Democrats.

>Much the same way that Americans will all claim to be democrats I'm not a democrat and I'm American.

What's wrong with democracy?

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#19
post #5

Exactly. I don't know why everyone including the big tech companies fell for the BLM grift so that they could scam their 'supporters' into taking the money and now running off with their donations which was used to buy properties, mansions, etc. How could they be so gullible?

A lot of people who could have raised this issue were shouted at for being racist, anti-black, etc. no matter if their concerns were valid. https://twitter.com/Sean_Kev/status/1488195035418013701

Sean Kevin Campbell's article was some great investigative journalism. Highly recommend reading to anyone interested in deeper knowledge about this controversy. I've seen several pundits (on "both" sides) regurgitate his work inaccurately, so think reading his article directly is important.

(article linked in that tweet)

https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/01/black-lives-matter-f...

Re: Amazon suspends Black Lives Matter from its charity platform

#20

Makes sense, although there are lot of other "charities" that I'm pretty sure have no accountability. I'm guessing this one got removed cause it is under the most scrutiny by the public.

Or, it's because the IRS revoked their tax exempt status. https://apps.irs.gov/app/eos/detailsPage?ein=473691474&name=... Amazon doesn't really get a choice in the matter here.

That's a different and completely unrelated [1] organization that happens to have a similar name (Black Lives Matter Foundation vs Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation).

[1] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/black-lives-mat...

Post reply on HN