Live data from Hacker News

KeePassXC – Cross-Platform Password Manager

keepassxc.org

31–39 of 39 posts

Re: KeePassXC – Cross-Platform Password Manager

#31
post #28

KeePassXC + syncthing to sync the database file has been a solid combo of secret storage across all my devices, even Android phones. It's been working perfectly for 5 years now.

I have the same setup. One question, is there a Syncthing solution for iOS devices?

I looked into this a while back and Syncthing does not have an iOS app.

Re: KeePassXC – Cross-Platform Password Manager

#32
post #3

If I'm a happy KeePass user, and everything just works, is there any reason to switch to KeePassXC?

KeePass is made in C#, KeePassXC is made in C++. That alone might make your life easier if you need to use it in Mac or Linux, because I've found making Keepass' C# plugins work on mono is tricky, while KeePassXC doesn't need plugins for my use cases.

Edit: Looks like KeePassXC doesn't support plugins, and I hadn't noticed :/

Re: KeePassXC – Cross-Platform Password Manager

#33

KeePassXC + syncthing to sync the database file has been a solid combo of secret storage across all my devices, even Android phones. It's been working perfectly for 5 years now.

I went with this combo as well. My requirement was to sync my password database across multiple platforms (Windows, Linux, MacOS, and Android). KeePassXC works great on all the desktop OSes, and there's a couple choices for Android apps (I chose Keepass2Android).

It does have downsides, mostly around Syncthing: it's a bit of a battery hog and there's no iOS app. If either one of those ever becomes enough of a problem for me I can just switch it out for one of the more normal cloud storage providers though.

Re: KeePassXC – Cross-Platform Password Manager

#34
I like keepassxc.

For everybody trying it: avoid the password sharing feature. It's currently hopelessly broken. The last time I had a look it was a known issue that needs major rework. IMO that can be worked around be keeping a dedicated database for shared scenarios -- albeit not practically fine grained for every secret. (I don't care, yet)

Re: KeePassXC – Cross-Platform Password Manager

#36
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Because usability and UI do make improvements (probably an unpopular opinion on HN...) and follows trends, KeePass does look completely outdated, the UX is completely outdated and the – nowadays – most important part, browser integration, is only achieved via plugins. This is a pretty good point, even if i'm of the opposite opinion! To me, KeePass is wonderfully boring and usable, much like spreadsheet software (e.…

>To me, KeePass is wonderfully boring and usable, much like spreadsheet software (e.g. LibreOffice Calc), it doesn't waste space and does everything i need it to. agreed. keepassxc has much more padding/whitespace than keepass. >Furthermore, browser integration actually wouldn't be something i want - i'd prefer to keep those pieces of software as far from one another as possible. I'm mixed on browser integration. On…

If I'm not mistaken you can set KeePass (and KPXC) to show a confirmation popup before the browser extension can access a password for a website. But I haven't used this function so I'm not 100% sure.

Re: KeePassXC – Cross-Platform Password Manager

#37
post #28

KeePassXC + syncthing to sync the database file has been a solid combo of secret storage across all my devices, even Android phones. It's been working perfectly for 5 years now.

I have the same setup. One question, is there a Syncthing solution for iOS devices?

Apparently it's the longest running Issue on their Github: https://github.com/syncthing/syncthing/issues/102

Edit to add:

There is Möbius Sync [0] but I didn't have much success with it. It did work but not quite the way I wanted so eventually I just deleted it.

On Reddit [1] people suggest all sorts of workarounds using other sync tools, like iCloud or NextCloud. Not ideal.

[0] https://www.mobiussync.com/ [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Syncthing/comments/ese82l/ios_users...

Re: KeePassXC – Cross-Platform Password Manager

#39

KeePassXC + syncthing to sync the database file has been a solid combo of secret storage across all my devices, even Android phones. It's been working perfectly for 5 years now.

This is exactly how I do the very same thing, and same as yourself, it's been working pretty much flawlessly for me since day one. Mine's Linux + Android, but I assume the same would work across any operating systems supported by SyncThing and KeePassXC.
Post reply on HN