Live data from Hacker News

Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

nature.com

11–20 of 351 posts

Re: Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

#11
post #4

Sweet let's crank up the generation ships. Of course picking a suitably inspiring name should be the first priority. Unity? Terra Nova? Gaia? On a more serious note is this a good candidate for JWST, would it be able to infer chemical composition from the planet's spectrum or something? Awesome though we went from (in my lifetime) learning at school that other planets have never been observed, to finding them sprinkl…

Generation ships will take some time to get ready. We can railgun tardigrades and aphanizomenon flos-aquae there this year and let evolution do the rest. By the time we (or, more likely, the descendants of cockroaches) get there, it will be teeming with DNA-based life.

We should perhaps be extra sure that there isn't life there already, before starting to attack a distant planet with terraforming weaponry.

Re: Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

#12
post #4

Sweet let's crank up the generation ships. Of course picking a suitably inspiring name should be the first priority. Unity? Terra Nova? Gaia? On a more serious note is this a good candidate for JWST, would it be able to infer chemical composition from the planet's spectrum or something? Awesome though we went from (in my lifetime) learning at school that other planets have never been observed, to finding them sprinkl…

Unrelated but I keep reading that abbreviation as Json Web Space Token

Re: Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

#13
Sadly, as discussed here, the technical problems with propulsion systems for interstellar travel are non-trivial:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29638529

Of course that doesn't necessarily preclude a nearby higher level Kardashev Civilization becoming interested in all the noise we're making and heading over.

As we put up systems beyond Webb, it may be possible to observe a hypothetical inbound craft / fleet some years off, which would have interesting effects on our current human society, once it became generally known..

My suspicion is that the social media generation would react a lot worse than the radio generation did to the 1938 broadcast of H. G. Wells' War of the Worlds:

https://www.space.com/40435-finding-aliens-humanity-reaction...

Re: Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

#15
Another point for anyone considering whether we should send a space-probe there...

The current fastest man-man object is the Helios 2 space-probe, reaching something like 25 000 kilometres per hour. Proxima Centauri is 1.3020 parsecs away from Earth.

So, just diving one by the other, we'd looking at something like 18 000 years as a rough order of magnitude for sending something from Earth to Proxima Centauri.

You'd be much better off waiting, well, even a thousand years for technology to improve rather than sending something now.

Note: this is a very dodgy line of reasoning. The Helios probe got a massive speed boost from a close encounter with the sun. But even if the speed is wrong by a factor of ten, we're still looking at somewhere between a thousand and a hundred-thousand years.

Re: Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

#16
"Earth-like planet"?

It orbits the star every 5 days; it's a quarter of the earth's mass. It's also a tenth the distance from its star that Mercury is from the Sun. It's earth-like only in that its temperature is consistent with there being liquid water.

Re: Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

#18

Just for reference, the planet is 4.0×10^13 kilometres away, if we send our fastest ever probe, and assume it averages the top speed of 586,800 km/h all the way there, it will still take 7,781 years to reach the planet.

Under 1g acceleration about 3.5 years

https://www.omnicalculator.com/physics/space-travel

Re: Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

#19
post #17

We can't even work out how to run our own planet in a consistent and consensual way, I say leave it to the other more civil aliens to inhabit, otherwise we'll end up with another broken planet.

I don't think space is so crowded and we got enough empty rocks up there.

Re: Earth-like planet spotted orbiting Sun’s closest star

#20
post #17

We can't even work out how to run our own planet in a consistent and consensual way, I say leave it to the other more civil aliens to inhabit, otherwise we'll end up with another broken planet.

What is there to break on a lifeless planet?
Post reply on HN