Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?

news.ycombinator.com

101–110 of 365 posts

Re: Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?

#101
post #43

The Bible - as an original source of all types of stories and narratives you’ll find in 99% of all fiction books and movies. New Testament — as an original source of most of moral principles and ideas modern european civilization is based upon (also fundamental stories and narratives).

I’ve read the Bible and frankly I wouldn’t recommend. Putting aside that the different translations can sometimes drastically change the meaning of some stories, the English Bible as a whole is harder to grok than Shakespeare. Then there are issues about how it was written by man, in the literal sense. Female testaments were left out. And some of the male testaments were only included hundreds of years after the deat…

I second the commenters that counter-argue that just because a book is hard, it does not make it a bad book.

While it's hard to understand for the following reasons

- It's not "a book" but a canon of dozens of books bound together, written by different people;

- cultural distance: Middle East versus West;

- temporal distance: authored approx. 2000 years ago;

almost every book written afterwards refers to it explicitly or implicitly or depends on it in some way, and you will never understand the later works fully without having read some of the Bible.

To read the Bible, a layperson needs guidance. Having said this parts of the New Testament are more easy to follow. For those who prefer to watch, this movie https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058715/ (created by an atheist to better understand it all) uses the original words of the Gospel of St. Matthew, and the result got praise from the Vatican, ironically.

Re: Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?

#103
Definitely The Hitch-Hiker’s Guide To The Galaxy. If only so they would understand The Answer and the latent absurdity of our civilization.

Although the bit about the plague from a dirty phone might be a little too close for comfort these days (but that just goes to show how fascinatingly “complete” the book is).

Re: Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?

#105
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> 1) “How to win friends and influence people” The folks I know who have this on their bookshelf tend to be dishonest, manipulative, self-centered pricks.

They didn't read it then. I read it a while ago and from what I can remember there was nothing about manipulation or dishonesty. In fact I'm fairly sure manipulation and dishonesty were explicitly discouraged.

I never read it cover to cover, but paged through some random parts and it certainly contained guidance away from authenticity and towards identifying and saying/doing the right things to achieve your goals.

It's not a bad thing to read though, but more in terms of understanding what your competition is reading and tools they're potentially weaponizing (lots of copies have been sold). Just like I recommended my sister at least skim The Game when she was frustrated by her post-divorce dating experiences, which based on her description were at least partially being influenced by assholes having read it.

Re: Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?

#108
post #80
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve read the Bible and frankly I wouldn’t recommend. Putting aside that the different translations can sometimes drastically change the meaning of some stories, the English Bible as a whole is harder to grok than Shakespeare. Then there are issues about how it was written by man, in the literal sense. Female testaments were left out. And some of the male testaments were only included hundreds of years after the deat…

> Then there are issues about how it was written by man, in the literal sense. Female testaments were left out. Does the gender of a books author really matter?

It does when those books were purposely excluded because the author was female. It also matters a lot when one of the books excluded was written by the person who was actually closest to Jesus too. Thus her accounts should surely matter at least as much as the mens (probably more so in reality).

The New Testament was collated in an era when organised religion was used as a tool for man to retain control. To that end, much of content of the “modern” Bible is about man and why one should follow man because he speaks on “behalf of God”.

This isn’t some new morality interpretation in the new age of political correctness either. This is an observation that’s gone back as long as I’ve been alive (40+ years) because, as I’ve said above, the testaments of those closest to Jesus were even excluded.

Re: Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?

#109
Things nobody tells you about relationship dynamics when you are young. Whats a head of you emontionaly? I recommend these to my son.

Erich Fromm The Art of Loving

David schnarch Passionate Marriage: Sex, Love & Intimacy in emotionally committed relationships.

And before you get married... Get some new perspective why ...

Wolfgang gädecke, Sexuality, Partnership and Marriage : From a Spiritual Perspective

Re: Ask HN: What is one book you would recommend everyone to read?

#110
post #101
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve read the Bible and frankly I wouldn’t recommend. Putting aside that the different translations can sometimes drastically change the meaning of some stories, the English Bible as a whole is harder to grok than Shakespeare. Then there are issues about how it was written by man, in the literal sense. Female testaments were left out. And some of the male testaments were only included hundreds of years after the deat…

I second the commenters that counter-argue that just because a book is hard, it does not make it a bad book. While it's hard to understand for the following reasons - It's not "a book" but a canon of dozens of books bound together, written by different people; - cultural distance: Middle East versus West; - temporal distance: authored approx. 2000 years ago; almost every book written afterwards refers to it explicitl…

> you will never understand the later works fully without having read some of the Bible

Generations of kids have grown up understanding stories just fine without having read the Bible.

Post reply on HN