Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?

oncircles.com

21–30 of 144 posts

Re: Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?

#21
post #13

I tried to sign up on my iPhone and it didn't work. I think this is a great idea. What are your strategies to make users to bring their friends?

Sorry about that! At which point did it stop working?

Most bug feedback I've gotten since going live has been at the verification page for your phone number. If this is the case, the solution has been to go back a page and submit your number again - happy to support here over email if you'd like!

Our strategy revolves around the intimacy of the sharing that the app has created so far. Despite being simple (and buggy it seems!), you really only need 2-3 family/close friends to make the app joyful - successful or not we've aimed set up the app so that you get that experience as soon as possible.

An (non mom-test) example here is in how it improved my close relationships. My aunt passed away from cancer a few months ago, but before that we were able to share moments on Circles that otherwise would have not made it into chat and/or the typical social apps. Beyond holding the experience dearly, the possibilities of intimate sharing outside of typical social media made her invite her friends.

We can of course bake a bunch of viral marketing features into the product (and have started doing so) but getting this single thing right is by far top of the list.

Re: Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?

#22
I know its frowned upon in HN to talk monetization early, but if I am not the product, how do you plan to sustain and grow this? I believe social media inherently has only one product, social interactions. If you users are not being charged, they are the product. Do you plan to charge content creators? Do you plan to charge for premium features? I ask because otherwise it might just go the way of Google+ and disappear in a few years.

One idea might be to go the Pateron way but with a free tier. But then its something akin to youtube/tiktok not really a social network.

Re: Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?

#24
The screenshots actually have the 2 things I thought about before:

- circles from Google

- combined pictures ( haven't seen this one and is a must!)

I'm downloading.

Edit 1: Required contacts ( Ugh). But - Say hello to @God ( God, i really hope i can change the handle later on) = No forbidden username list probably.

Edit 2: Ugh. Invite only lol. Disallowed contacts & storage again.

Re: Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?

#25

Great work on the app! I haven't used it yet, as I'm reluctant to download an app or even sign up for an app without a clear demo of how it works. The video on the landing page explains the principles of the app (circles, privacy, etc) but it doesn't show how it works in practice. As someone who also abhors social media, how is this different from those experiences? How are the circles managed? How are my posts and f…

Thanks for all these comments, all noted. You're right, a demo would be nice and also super simple to do.

Also a great point, as mentioned in the OP, I've been off social media for some time because I hated them. So bar the standard stuff of onboarding, posting a piece of content etc. We've pushed to do the exact opposite of a normal social media app. Some examples:

- You must add someone to a Circle to see them in your feed, and share to them. - Reactions and comments are only shown between mutual contacts. So if you're viewing a post - Names and Posts are encrypted at rest, and we don't ask/take any data we don't need. We want to push this further in time but our intent is that we actively eschew collecting specific data about individuals, so don't have incentive to make the app driven by ads/addictive features.

Google+ was interesting but ultimately was just Facebook with more friction (eg. connect with as many things and people as possible). We're using the Circles concept to target the inner parts of your network, rather than everyone. Still a WIP, though!

Also good feedback, we focused on mobile because of limited resource but a web option would be great. Is there a specific reason it's a no go for social apps?

Re: Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?

#26
post #19

Looks quite nice. But I did use Google+ and it was just no one else really using those features. So nope I'm not seeing the benefit of syncing my contacts with your service. WhatsApp won in our family for sharing.

Thanks!

That's true, same with Facebook links and in some ways, close friends on Instagram. Our argument here is that rather than having it is as one-of-many features, we're focused on making a joyful experience around this single feature, creating a different space for sharing.

Feedback noted though!

Re: Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?

#27

The screenshots actually have the 2 things I thought about before: - circles from Google - combined pictures ( haven't seen this one and is a must!) I'm downloading. Edit 1: Required contacts ( Ugh). But - Say hello to @God ( God, i really hope i can change the handle later on) = No forbidden username list probably. Edit 2: Ugh. Invite only lol. Disallowed contacts & storage again.

Hey there - Thanks for this & nice handle (you can change it later)!

The app is invite only but I've posted an invite code in the OP (FULLCIRCLE), also will remove the invite proxy in the onboarding in the next update. Hopefully you'll still try!

Re: Show HN: What do you think of my new social app?

#28

I know its frowned upon in HN to talk monetization early, but if I am not the product, how do you plan to sustain and grow this? I believe social media inherently has only one product, social interactions. If you users are not being charged, they are the product. Do you plan to charge content creators? Do you plan to charge for premium features? I ask because otherwise it might just go the way of Google+ and disappea…

I came to ask the same question. I like the concept but if its going to disappear after 12 months its not worth the effort.
Post reply on HN