Live data from Hacker News

The process behind our startup's logo design - draftswork shown

blog.groovehq.com

41–46 of 46 posts

Re: The process behind our startup's logo design - draftswork shown

#41

I don't think it's that great of a logo. At the very least it is too detailed to scale well, the shell will be completely lost at smaller sizes turning into a blob of flesh color. The use of desaturated pastels is not a typical choice for a technical project. It is more fit for something soft, girly, perhaps creative. Also there is a disconnect between the name and the symbol. You tell me "Groove", I will remember Gr…

The bigger question to me was: What does Groove do? Branding should be about what you want to communicate about the company rather than the decoration process of picking out a color scheme. If you want to understand why this branding isn't working read the mission statement: "Groove is a hosted customer support and engagement platform that helps companies manage customer support across all types of channels - email,…

Logo use on internet at scale is infrequent and colors trump visual metaphor. These colors are distinctive as is the seemingly abstract arrangement of them which is really what counts. The Apple logo has been assailed from day one and contrary to michaelpinto's assertion, a logo never held back anybody....unless you feel the Yahoo logo "Y!" was a self inflicted decisive blow....and how do you construct "slightly vague" and "great job" into whole cloth. Help me here with how any of this matters, if the logo (which will more often then not be a chip on a nav bar) isn't evocative but is none-the-less a distinctive abstract color assemblage?

Re: The process behind our startup's logo design - draftswork shown

#45

I'm really curious what Alex's reaction is to the discussion here. He posted a link to the blog post, so he must be reading it, no? The comments so far seem pretty negative, and not really for unimportant reasons. The two main issues I see are: (1) too complicated as well as lacking contrast, so it will not print well on t-shirts, letterhead, and business cards and (2) the logo does not look like a shell without seei…

That guy Alex is probably pumped to see so many trolls logging hours on his thread :) - point "(1)" is simply not true. Tshirts, letterhead, and business cards included. Friend put me onto this thread simply because the trolling was so horrendous, and you guys did not disappoint. Stay strong, troll on.

Re: The process behind our startup's logo design - draftswork shown

#46
Why is everyone so negative?! I really like all the designs and seeing your thought process of how you develop an idea.

My favorite is the combination of the type and simple shell design (the one without the pink/blue/green colorway).

It could be cool to introduce color into that design with some sort of ribbon that flows through the type? Maybe even using the same color palette? ...just an idea.

keep up the good work!

Post reply on HN