Live data from Hacker News

Rethinking Sheet Music, With A Few Bells And Whistles

npr.org

1–10 of 43 posts

Re: Rethinking Sheet Music, With A Few Bells And Whistles

#2
Congrats, Dan! What a great write-up. So glad to see how far this has come.

Leaving aside the practical matters native to the iPad, I think not having an extensive classical selection is one of the best ways you could be dinged. It speaks the app's value and a desire to use the app more. And it leaves the door open for a followup story.

Re: Rethinking Sheet Music, With A Few Bells And Whistles

#6
I think a killer feature for this (or a competitor...) would be auto-turning pages using the ambient audio. "While I am playing piano and have no hands I have to deftly change the music, therefore I need another human" is a huge pain point for performing pianists.

Re: Rethinking Sheet Music, With A Few Bells And Whistles

#7

I think a killer feature for this (or a competitor...) would be auto-turning pages using the ambient audio. "While I am playing piano and have no hands I have to deftly change the music, therefore I need another human " is a huge pain point for performing pianists.

Tonara does this.

Re: Rethinking Sheet Music, With A Few Bells And Whistles

#8

I think a killer feature for this (or a competitor...) would be auto-turning pages using the ambient audio. "While I am playing piano and have no hands I have to deftly change the music, therefore I need another human " is a huge pain point for performing pianists.

Tonara does this.

I'm excited about Tonara, but the app itself seems like a tech demo for that specific technology.

They have yet to experience the pain of a thousand cuts that (that my team and I have gone through) that is working with the music publishing industry.

The thing with these apps is that people who don't really understand them group them all together. "Oh, another music-y app for fancy music people!"

While their app now is not remotely a competitor, if they actually get some real funding, they could pivot in a number of ways to compete against apps like mine, because they've been able to position themselves well in the "music app startup" slot by presenting at TC.

Re: Rethinking Sheet Music, With A Few Bells And Whistles

#9
The main problem with sheet music is copyright law. Its differences across Europe will make anyone's head hurt. If that weren't enough, the established publishing industry is extremely conservative. In my experience the musicians --that is users-- would be the last and least hurdle.

Re: Rethinking Sheet Music, With A Few Bells And Whistles

#10

The main problem with sheet music is copyright law. Its differences across Europe will make anyone's head hurt. If that weren't enough, the established publishing industry is extremely conservative. In my experience the musicians --that is users-- would be the last and least hurdle.

This times a million.
Post reply on HN