Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

news.ycombinator.com

41–49 of 49 posts

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#41
This is great stuff. This could end up like a wikipedia for web developers. I've been wanting to do something like this for myself. With all the options available out there, its much easier to process when everything is organized.

Interesting that google had this as an internal webpage. I wonder what other really useful tools companies use that could benefit us if it were public.

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#42
post #7

I can see the value in something like this, especially for more novice web developers who may not know the terms to search for in Google or StackOverflow to find what they need. I understand it's rough, but here are something of the things I was expecting to see while I was browsing around: - Some "category" pages, like dbm, are missing definitions. It would be great if definitions were present on every category page…

We have added definitions to most of the category pages, please let us know your feedback.

Thanks for all your suggestions, will follow up on the rest of the suggestions!

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#43
post #38

It might be a good idea to tag the age of articles because some may be complaints or has missing features that would get resolved. Also, no Source Control (Git/SVN/etc) or Configuration Control (Chef/Puppet/etc)?

Based on your suggestion, we have added source control, configuration control, and deployment tools categories.

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#44

Great. I'd suggest arranging the categories in a rough data flow, so webserver would be near the "outside" (top?), wsqi inside that, frameworks inside that. wsgi might become part of a larger cgi-ish category: app container? app connector? You'd include fcgi and the various php equivalents in there; maybe subcategories. Debatable: firewalls? Virtual environments like virtualenv and whatever the other guys use.

We have roughly sorted the categories from bottom to top stack order, let us know your feedback :)

We have added environment managers as a category (virtualenv, rvm, rbenv, bundler)

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#45
post #12

Interesting idea. Suggestion: sort the categories at the top by how likely a project is to need/use them. Without getting into religious arguments, I think a fair example would be "language" and "webserver" should sort higher than "graph-store" and "mapreduce". Also might be a good idea to define the categories for newbies. Most of the categories will need explanation for newbies. Cool idea, though. I used to use jak…

We have roughly sorted the categories from bottom to top stack order, let us know your feedback :)

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#46
post #13

Cool idea! Definitely makes research a lot easier! Any reason why CSS isn`t on the list of languages? My web stack in the past has included CSS pre-processers, like LESS and Sass.

Based on your suggestion, we have added the CSS category (lesscss, scss).

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#47
We could merge our efforts, someway. I provide some projects' metadata (along their history) via http://appdate.it . It's really a rough job to do... mostly web page scraping, because a structured way to present those informations does not exist and if it would exist, well, it should be embraced by each project.

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#48
post #33
post #29

Nice idea. Could you include an approximation of each components popularity or longevity? This would allow people to know if they are picking mainstream or more obscure/specialised/enterprise/unstable/etc components.

yeah. any ideas on how to measure this?

google trends/search traffic

Re: Show HN: Stack Parts - a way to find possible parts for your stack

#49
post #45
post #12

Interesting idea. Suggestion: sort the categories at the top by how likely a project is to need/use them. Without getting into religious arguments, I think a fair example would be "language" and "webserver" should sort higher than "graph-store" and "mapreduce". Also might be a good idea to define the categories for newbies. Most of the categories will need explanation for newbies. Cool idea, though. I used to use jak…

We have roughly sorted the categories from bottom to top stack order, let us know your feedback :)

I can see that it's sorted now, but I don't think I explained my intention well before. What I meant was the order should be something like:

- language

- sql

- webserver

- webframework

- sourcecontrol

...

- stuff most people don't use on their projects, like mapreduce and graph-store

Also, the tooltip definitions are helpful but it's not obvious that they are there. I only knew they were there because you said so here. :-)

Good luck!

Post reply on HN