Live data from Hacker News

Dark Web – Justice League

analyst1.com

21–30 of 211 posts

Re: Dark Web – Justice League

#21

Is this anarchism? That being naturally emergent formal processes for things which would normally be handled by the government/legal system.

No. There would need to be many more meetings and countless committees from groups of random people who all acclaim to hold some sort of power.

> There would need to be many more meetings and countless committees from groups of random people who all acclaim to hold some sort of power.

That's a description of our statist status quo :)

Re: Dark Web – Justice League

#22

These kinds of alternative justice systems always seem fascinating to me. I feel like a sociological study on "alternative forms of justice" could be very fruitful.

Interestingly, Medieval Iceland had a polycentric legal system where you could sell the wrong done to you to someone who had more money to prosecute.

There's an interesting discussion/description in "The Machinery of Freedom", a book about anarchocapitalism.

It's freely available online - http://www.daviddfriedman.com/The_Machinery_of_Freedom_.pdf

Re: Dark Web – Justice League

#23

Is this anarchism? That being naturally emergent formal processes for things which would normally be handled by the government/legal system.

No. There would need to be many more meetings and countless committees from groups of random people who all acclaim to hold some sort of power.

No post body was provided.

Re: Dark Web – Justice League

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No. There would need to be many more meetings and countless committees from groups of random people who all acclaim to hold some sort of power.

> There would need to be many more meetings and countless committees from groups of random people who all acclaim to hold some sort of power. That's a description of our statist status quo :)

I think that’s the joke

Re: Dark Web – Justice League

#26

Is this anarchism? That being naturally emergent formal processes for things which would normally be handled by the government/legal system.

Closer to a gang style parallel government structure. The penalties are backed up by banishment from the group rather than violence.

Re: Dark Web – Justice League

#27
This just shows that people naturally gravitate toward a system of social harmony and the rule of law, as it lets you reasonably adjust your behavior, as the expectations are formalized, and everyone else is assumed to be abiding by them.

The irony is that real world is increasingly moving away from that, toward the "everyone for themselves, nothing matters" chaos.

Re: Dark Web – Justice League

#28

Is this anarchism? That being naturally emergent formal processes for things which would normally be handled by the government/legal system.

I don't think it's naturally emergent. It's just another case of a centralized entity making some rules people need to follow or else they get banned. It's not too dissimilar from what would happen on eBay if someone complains about a seller.

Re: Dark Web – Justice League

#30
post #26

Is this anarchism? That being naturally emergent formal processes for things which would normally be handled by the government/legal system.

Closer to a gang style parallel government structure. The penalties are backed up by banishment from the group rather than violence.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN