Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Clover (YC S20) – Notes, whiteboarding, and daily planner in one tool

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 109 posts

Re: Launch HN: Clover (YC S20) – Notes, whiteboarding, and daily planner in one tool

#71
Delighted to see this. Nearly a decade ago I made a sort of virtual desk blotter which let you put notes or drawings anywhere. It was during paternity leave after my first child was born and I was in that weird head space of free association caused by extreme sleep deprivation. I've since discovered One Note which has that as a core UX device, but I still think mine was nicer, though I never really finished it.

Clover's Surface seems like a grown-up, slick version of what I was trying to achieve on my own. So I'm really pleased you're making a business out of it. And it's a desktop app!

I wish Apple hadn't ditched the whole OpenDoc thing - it'd be so good to draw a frame and have that frame be, say, an Affinity Designer document that you could edit directly in the Surface. (A bit like OLE with an Excel sheet in a Word doc in the old days on Windows.) This feels like such an amazing organizational model for complex, multi-tool, project-based work. At least, that's how I'll use it. But this is only 2 minutes into my use of the product...

Congrats, it's great. And the price is attractive too - this is one I really hope I end up subscribing to as I go through the trial.

Re: Launch HN: Clover (YC S20) – Notes, whiteboarding, and daily planner in one tool

#72
As others have mentioned, I want to try it first without having to create an account and give you my personal information.

Also, your FAQ says “We do not track any personally identifiable information. Additionally we do not sell or share user data with third parties.” but your privacy policy says “ We may share your personal information with third party advertising companies to market our own Services and grow our Services’ user base, such as to provide targeted marketing about our own Services via third-party services as described in the advertising purposes section above.”

I would like to use sign in with apple so I don’t have to use my personal email, especially considering you cannot change your account email at this time.

Looks like a great app from what I can see, but between obsidian & procreate my needs are covered without a subscription.

Re: Launch HN: Clover (YC S20) – Notes, whiteboarding, and daily planner in one tool

#75
Wonderful take on what's missing in current notetaking. Agree that text editors are not good for thinking (forcing the constraint of linearity "Great ideas don't flow out of us with a beginning, a middle and an end"

I use only native apps for thinking. Latency kills my train of thought. And web apps have plenty! Both typing latency (typometer, a java app, shows 45ms in best case scenario!) and creation/navigation latency (going back to a previous page, creating a new one). But I know my requirements are pretty unique, I'm not representative of the general public. Best of luck!

Re: Launch HN: Clover (YC S20) – Notes, whiteboarding, and daily planner in one tool

#77
Loving it so far, and all I've explored is the Daily Notes. My intention is to try it long-term.

The major missing feature that jumps out at me is the "create link" UX - I'd love to be able to highlight some text and paste a url from my clipboard to create a link. This is how Notion, Slack and GitHub work, and it's fast becoming a must-have!

Re: Launch HN: Clover (YC S20) – Notes, whiteboarding, and daily planner in one tool

#78
Congrats for the launch, it all looks very polished!

"Surface" is the killer feature for me. Been waiting for someone to build this for a while.

Conceptual question: isn't Document just a degenerate case of Surface? Can we just have one type of page ("Leaves" ;))? Document-like functionality could be exposed through the Text tool or as a separate "text editor".

In the same vein, Favorites can be just a Label.

Re: Launch HN: Clover (YC S20) – Notes, whiteboarding, and daily planner in one tool

#79
post #72

As others have mentioned, I want to try it first without having to create an account and give you my personal information. Also, your FAQ says “We do not track any personally identifiable information. Additionally we do not sell or share user data with third parties.” but your privacy policy says “ We may share your personal information with third party advertising companies to market our own Services and grow our Se…

It's weasel words. "Personal information" is not strictly "personally identifiable"; it doesn't matter that you can trivially de-anonymize people with even a modest amount of data.

Re: Launch HN: Clover (YC S20) – Notes, whiteboarding, and daily planner in one tool

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not from me. I personally don't need Dropbox but I can see the utility if a company want to share a 1 TB storage area between employees. I'm guessing that's how it's used since I've never used it.

>Besides I have free and open source I took a look in my note taking bookmarks folder to see what I meant. I thought Obsidian was open source but it's not. I was thinking of Joplin, which I haven't tried yet, but will today https://joplinapp.org/

Joplin is excellent. I'm a very happy user. But I also use my own WebDAV server to sync. It would be nice if they supported Seafile as a sync target, but they do currently support Nextcloud.
Post reply on HN