Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

news.ycombinator.com

631–640 of 805 posts

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#631
The use case I have seen for this is not salary negotiation - in fact, that is illegal in a non-zero number of states - but rather employment validation for home mortgages and marketing purposes.

Not saying it's better - but it's probably not being used the way it seems many pre-suppose here.

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#632

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, it didn't, it worked that WASP attendees of the bank manager's church got good rates and anyone born on the wrong side of town got turned away.

Bank of America was founded in 1904 -- well before credit scores became a thing -- to provide banking services to Italian-Americans, who could not usually obtain service from other banks due to ethnic discrimination.

Which is a good example of why you need financial systems to eliminate ethnic and religious biases in lending.

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#633

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe the point Beefy is making is that once they have your information, how can you prove that it was used in determining whether someone gets hired or how much their salary will be.

If it’s possible to sue for discrimination based on gender identity and orientation, why would it be impossible to sue for discrimination based on salary, if you have a record of prospective employer checking your salary records?

People in salary ranges are not a protected class; sexual orientation is protected.

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#634
post #423

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes it is, this is literally how credit works. You convince them you're credit worthy, they give you credit. If you don't like the particular information a credit company needs to trust you, then you try a different credit company. I don't follow how declining a credit company would affect your employment, is there something I'm missing there?

Having credit is not optional in modern society.

In the US, where credit cards are notably popular, 70-72% of people have a credit card. In other countries, it is less than this.

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#636
post #618
post #606

I've used this before as an employee. While it may also be a bulk dataset of employment information (which any HRS or payroll provider would have), the ostensible use of this solution is, to quote their homepage, "credentialed verifiers with permissible purpose access to income and employment data". Key words there are credentialed and permissible purpose . In other words, it's an automated way for me as an employee…

I think the issue is - do companies who give them information also get access to it for people outside their org Others have wrote this in the thread, but anecdotally I once tried to push up what I considered a low ball offer, and lied about my current comp. HR quickly said - no, thats not your current comp I'm pretty sure they didn't reach out to my current company to ask, so the only other option was abusing a syst…

I very much doubt it. The "Salary data is for sale" title is misleading; There's no way for me to go pay Equifax for access to u/shmatt's data. They might have some aggregate datasets for sale, removing PII.

The same goes for credit data; you (largely) can't run a credit check on me without my permission.

This is an HR service to ease the burden of legitimate requests for employment or salary data that you, as an employee, request.

More logically, employers wouldn't want other companies to be able to access their payroll information for competitive reasons.

I can't explain your previous experience; perhaps you were at a company with firm pay bands, and they knew you were already at the top of your current one?

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#637

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, I used the work number thing to verify my salary for my mortgage.

As in you had to interact directly with work number for that? Or do you mean that lender “magically” knew and pre-populated your salary info during application process?

Not the parent, but my lender magically knew with just my name, position, company, and SSN. FWIW

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#638

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Credit, bank checking (ChexSystems), and personal information aggregators like Lexis Nexis and Thomson Reuters Clear ought to be abolished or curbed indeed. I hate to bring trans politics into this. I'm sure that's the last thing anybody wants to hear about right now. However we are a class of people whose sexuality can be unfairly identified by these databases.

> However we are a class of people whose sexuality can be unfairly identified by these databases. Good perspective and thanks for sharing it. I am curious about your choice of words though. You said "sexuality" and not "gender identity". Is there some reason why? I've always thought of the term sexuality to be how you feel about others. Or is that what you meant here?

Gender identity falls under the umbrella of sexuality. I use less-polite terms to remind people that it's the most excruciatingly private details of my life on some bullshit report. One time while applying for an apartment, a boomer broker sarcastically exclaimed, "Well, THAT'S a valid life choice!" to me. Last year I encountered a professional whose mind was blown by this information and asked me if I've had surgery. It's wrong that this is at the mercy of a newish industry that exists to track individuals' merit in make-believe points.

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#639
post #598
post #450

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think one should not forget that Denmark's society is mostly homogenous. When you have a vastly dominant, culturally homogenous group, it's relatively easy to trust and support one another. In a highly diverse country like the US, where the average New Yorker or new immigrant will have a completely different culture and world view from the average Joe in Missouri, and that's just two examples out of many, it's very…

I hate hearing this argument. Simply because I'm living proof of the opposite: I'm not a native Swede, I immigrated here, I integrated into society by looking at its values, identifying with most of them and sharing those forward. I became a Swede and it has nothing to do with being born Nordic or into a homogeneous culture. This hand-waving argument on why America is exceptional is really misplaced. America has issu…

I realize this is just proving your point, but it also demontrates why the US doesn't really see the current culture as an issue:

GDP per capita:

USA: 63,543.58 USD

SWE: 51,925.71 USD

(for reference) UK: 40,284.64 USD

These are all for 2020.

Re: Tell HN: Salary data is for sale

#640
post #450

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think one should not forget that Denmark's society is mostly homogenous. When you have a vastly dominant, culturally homogenous group, it's relatively easy to trust and support one another. In a highly diverse country like the US, where the average New Yorker or new immigrant will have a completely different culture and world view from the average Joe in Missouri, and that's just two examples out of many, it's very…

The reason the US does nothing about climate change, privacy, inequality, etc. is lack of homogeneity? I'd like to see some evidence of the connection. Most of those policies are opposed by the same political grouping. The US has accomplished plenty of things in the past. Homogeneity depends on the definition of the groups. Most people in the US speak English, have a smartphone, etc. The US has long unified behind id…

>The reason the US does nothing about climate change, privacy, inequality, etc. is lack of homogeneity

I don't agree with the general point, but I do think the GOP funding class uses the US's heterogeneity as a wedge to distract from those issues (or anything else that would cost them money). See all of the culture wars.

What's the one big thing congress passed during the Trump years? The tax cut. That's not a mistake.

Post reply on HN