Live data from Hacker News

How to make your user interface CRAP

usabilityfriction.com

1–10 of 10 posts

Re: How to make your user interface CRAP

#2
IMHO, using the word "CRAP" to describe good practices seems like a bad idea. I thought the article was going to be a rant about some UIs the author didn't like... instead it was useful advice. I'm glad I clicked through, but "CRAP" didn't help that.

Re: How to make your user interface CRAP

#3
post #2

IMHO, using the word "CRAP" to describe good practices seems like a bad idea. I thought the article was going to be a rant about some UIs the author didn't like... instead it was useful advice. I'm glad I clicked through, but "CRAP" didn't help that.

This person didn't invent the term CRAP to define good design; it's been around for longer than I can remember.

Re: How to make your user interface CRAP

#4
post #3
post #2

IMHO, using the word "CRAP" to describe good practices seems like a bad idea. I thought the article was going to be a rant about some UIs the author didn't like... instead it was useful advice. I'm glad I clicked through, but "CRAP" didn't help that.

This person didn't invent the term CRAP to define good design; it's been around for longer than I can remember.

It's still a poor term for positive reinforcement...

Re: How to make your user interface CRAP

#5
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This person didn't invent the term CRAP to define good design; it's been around for longer than I can remember.

It's still a poor term for positive reinforcement...

...and makes it nearly impossible to separate the crap from the CRAP!

Re: How to make your user interface CRAP

#6
post #3
post #2

IMHO, using the word "CRAP" to describe good practices seems like a bad idea. I thought the article was going to be a rant about some UIs the author didn't like... instead it was useful advice. I'm glad I clicked through, but "CRAP" didn't help that.

This person didn't invent the term CRAP to define good design; it's been around for longer than I can remember.

Fair enough. But the people that need basic advice like this might not be aware of the term, and might not read the article as a result.

Re: How to make your user interface CRAP

#7
post #6
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This person didn't invent the term CRAP to define good design; it's been around for longer than I can remember.

Fair enough. But the people that need basic advice like this might not be aware of the term, and might not read the article as a result.

On the contrary, I think people are more likely to read it because of the "lol they said CRAP!" reaction. I guess that was why the term was 'invented', as opposed to PRAC or RAPC or another less-silly combination.

FYI this was where I first heard the acronym: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Non-Designers-Design-Book-Robin-Will...

Re: How to make your user interface CRAP

#8
post #2

IMHO, using the word "CRAP" to describe good practices seems like a bad idea. I thought the article was going to be a rant about some UIs the author didn't like... instead it was useful advice. I'm glad I clicked through, but "CRAP" didn't help that.

"How to make your user interface CARP on at people about what they should do."

CRAP isn't ironic, it's crap.

Re: How to make your user interface CRAP

#9
post #2

IMHO, using the word "CRAP" to describe good practices seems like a bad idea. I thought the article was going to be a rant about some UIs the author didn't like... instead it was useful advice. I'm glad I clicked through, but "CRAP" didn't help that.

[deleted]