Live data from Hacker News

Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising

reuters.com

21–30 of 330 posts

Re: Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising

#22
I traveled many post-Soviet countries in the past years with my old camping car. My personal impressions in Kazakhstan were frightening. A deeply corrupt state, much worse than Russia.

Aggressive armed bandits in police uniform tried to rob me several times. Kazakhstan is true mafia state where every part of the regime tries to enrich itself at the expanse of the people.

In contrast to the rich oil elite there are the normal people who often not even have tap water in the villages. And who live often in constant fear of being robbed by the armed forces.

But why is such a dysfunctional dictatorship so stable? Why did it last for three decades? The situation is very similar to Azerbaijan. I believe the answer is: it is backed by the West because a stable dictator in Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan guarantees the oil flow.

Re: Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising

#24
post #20

Just a few months ago it looked different, there were articles like this https://globalcomment.com/is-russia-losing-or-tightening-its... about US looking into getting an airbase and Tokayev trying to play it both sides. That probably won't happen anymore

The Armenians, too, and even Lukashenko tried to play both sides, get cozy with the West. They are probably/definitely not going to do that again.

Re: Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising

#25
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Foreign army in this context is just using a treaty you signed with an ally to request assistance. It’s as “foreign” as any NATO country’s army to another.

It'd be very strange if the French government asks Germany or Nato to quell the gilet-jaunes demo, wouldn't it?

[deleted]

Re: Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising

#26
post #13
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe you can help me here. My reading of the situation is that it was an attempted revolution against a dictator after he made a devastating unilateral decision to raise prices for a critical fuel. Am I missing something?

The raise of fuel prices was an immediate cause but it probably was long burning dissatisfaction with the economic hardships of the masses vs. prosperous kleptocratic elite. On the other hand it seems that the economy of Kazakhstan was one of the best among other stans. It is possible that prolonged covid restrictions also played the role.

No no no, it's all the war between US and Russia, people are just dust, they can only be manipulated! /s

(this is what every russian bot is saying)

Re: Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising

#28
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's very weird to see the President argue 'foreign interests' spark the unrest, and then promptly invites a foreign army to quell it. Who's falling for that?

Foreign army in this context is just using a treaty you signed with an ally to request assistance. It’s as “foreign” as any NATO country’s army to another.

Except that NATO countries are not run by tzars in their 70-ies whose only hope is to die quietly in bed, surrounded by elite killers.

Re: Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising

#29

I traveled many post-Soviet countries in the past years with my old camping car. My personal impressions in Kazakhstan were frightening. A deeply corrupt state, much worse than Russia. Aggressive armed bandits in police uniform tried to rob me several times. Kazakhstan is true mafia state where every part of the regime tries to enrich itself at the expanse of the people. In contrast to the rich oil elite there are th…

In the case of Azerbaijan, my understanding is that western European companies have just blanket bribed more or less every official they interact with up and down the Azeri government for the past few decades, to help them set up contracts that are grossly unfair to the Azeri public. Oil money that does go to Azerbaijan gets embezzled away, with those companies’ knowledge and implicit support.

I haven’t heard of anyone from e.g. BP getting punished for this, though I believe the British government asked it to investigate itself a few times.

Re: Russia sends troops to Kazakhstan to put down deadly uprising

#30
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Foreign army in this context is just using a treaty you signed with an ally to request assistance. It’s as “foreign” as any NATO country’s army to another.

It'd be very strange if the French government asks Germany or Nato to quell the gilet-jaunes demo, wouldn't it?

And yet intelligence agencies routinely spy for one another to get around those pesky warrant and probable cause requirements.
Post reply on HN