Live data from Hacker News

I Miss RSS

wilcosky.com

41–50 of 314 posts

Re: I Miss RSS

#41
post #33

This turned up in my RSS feed of hacker news. Yes, google basically killed RSS through embrace, extend, extinguish. There’s no money in democratizing self-publishing.

how do you have a RSS feed of HN? what links does it include out of the thousands that are posted here daily? also, can I ask you what service are you currently using for you RSS feed? thanks.

I personally use hnrss [1], and usually just display the frontpage [2].

[1]: https://hnrss.github.io/

[2]: https://hnrss.org/frontpage

Re: I Miss RSS

#42
I have a private Discord server that acts as an RSS reader via MonitoRSS[1]. It works great because Discord has really good notification configuration. Some feeds I want to know about immediately, others I only want to see when I check the news, and because I can mute channels I can let my friends use it as well. They set up their own feeds and I don't have to be alerted to it but I can go look if I'm interested in what they're reading lately.

All that is to say that RSS still works. What's missing is the original content creators of the early RSS world. Nowadays, most people create small, easy-to-write, easy-to-consume content in one of the walled gardens since the notifications, interactions, and network are all included for them.

[1]: https://monitorss.xyz/

Re: I Miss RSS

#43
post #22
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When Google reader shut down, I moved to feedly for like a week. Then I started getting anxiety that feedly would shut down too. Because if google could kill off a product i relied on, anyone could. And that got me into self hosting and running my own services. ttrss was basically my first self hosted thing almost a decade ago. It was great. And then it turned out the guy running it was a bit not pleasant, and I didn…

Having self-hosted for a long time, I find it's getting easier in a lot of ways what with Docker and all. I'm starting to wonder where "Sandstorm 2.0" is. Sandstorm, for those who don't know, was basically an attempt to make self hosting really viable, but was tragically ahead of its time because it predated Docker. So they burned tons of effort on sandboxing, and wrapping existing applications into their sandbox, an…

I've taken the self hosting journey to learn tons about docker, and kubernetes. (Disclaimer: Kubernetes is overkill for self hosting). Not because it was the easiest, but because it was a great way to learn about a technology that has benefited me in my job.

Nowadays, for me at least, it IS really easy to self-host anything. Get the docker image, add a deployment to my k8s cluster. Ship it. Getting to this point was less simple.

Re: I Miss RSS

#44
post #34

To be honest, I don't. Websites like Reddit or Hacker News are better because they provide popularity scores into the links, helping me filtered out junk links.

I read HN via an RSS feed over the front page. You can filter out junks just fine.

Re: I Miss RSS

#45
post #33

This turned up in my RSS feed of hacker news. Yes, google basically killed RSS through embrace, extend, extinguish. There’s no money in democratizing self-publishing.

how do you have a RSS feed of HN? what links does it include out of the thousands that are posted here daily? also, can I ask you what service are you currently using for you RSS feed? thanks.

There's probably more of them but if you look at the html (browsers used to have an icon for this...) there's a tag in there on the home page, so https://news.ycombinator.com/rss should be the feed

Re: I Miss RSS

#46
post #37
post #7

I still use RSS. I use Feedly to curate various RSS feeds and many website still have them, or at least the tech focussed ones. I used to be subscribed to more but some RSS feeds have such high traffic it's difficult to follow them, such as the BBC news feed. Feedly has a nice new feature [0] that makes an RSS feed out of a standard website, so that might be worth considering if you have some news sources that don't…

still ? It's not like there's something better out there

Like what?

I'm unaware of other ways to get consistent listings of new content at various sites in a machine readable format.

Re: I Miss RSS

#47
post #33

This turned up in my RSS feed of hacker news. Yes, google basically killed RSS through embrace, extend, extinguish. There’s no money in democratizing self-publishing.

how do you have a RSS feed of HN? what links does it include out of the thousands that are posted here daily? also, can I ask you what service are you currently using for you RSS feed? thanks.

[deleted]

Re: I Miss RSS

#48
The author paints it as some kind of conspiracy, but the simple truth is that RSS waned in popularity once push notifications became popular and widespread. Every user's RSS reader polling every website for changes every few minutes for all eternity is horribly inefficient and unfeasible to do on most platforms and devices today (especially on mobile). Pub/sub is the clear way forward, but it's just sad that there is no accepted standard for it.

Re: I Miss RSS

#49
I still use RSS on a daily basis, and it's great. I like Newsblur.com but there are a fair number of options based on your desire to self-host and/or use social features.

The primary thing I wish was better is a way to handle social commentary. Unfortunately this is an extremely hard problem to solve without allowing spamming and brigading.

Re: I Miss RSS

#50
I bought ReadKit for Mac a few years ago and still use it today. I still like having a nice standalone news reader. It even ties into my Instapaper account.
Post reply on HN