Live data from Hacker News

Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

tarahenley.substack.com

31–40 of 441 posts

Re: Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

#31
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

" Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith. " https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Quoted post unavailable.

Wait why are we not allowed to complain about trans people. Are they special in a way that makes them immune from being complained about?

Im fine with trans people. I am asking literally are we not allowed to complain about them.

Re: Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

#32
post #22

I'm not sure these sorts of articles provide much value on HN. By "these sorts of articles", I mean the ones that have claimed that "diversity efforts have gone too far this time ." Regardless of your support or opposition to diversity, I think one would agree that these rapidly turn into unproductive, highly divisive comment sections that are out of place with the rest of HN.

The title + substack domain are a good indication that this is going to be yet another culture war article.

Re: Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

#33

What clearly seems wrong is the requirement to fill out forms on the race and gender of people you interview, and to have quotas to control whose voice is heard based on those irrelevant traits (irrelevant relative to the individual person's life, ideas, experiences, ability to express themselves etc.) My policy is to refuse to give my gender or race. If everybody did this, high frequencies of "other" or "unknown" co…

I never fill out the preferred pronoun section that have suddenly made their way into forms.

I have a coworker who assigned “Lord” as his personal pronoun.

Re: Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

#36

What clearly seems wrong is the requirement to fill out forms on the race and gender of people you interview, and to have quotas to control whose voice is heard based on those irrelevant traits (irrelevant relative to the individual person's life, ideas, experiences, ability to express themselves etc.) My policy is to refuse to give my gender or race. If everybody did this, high frequencies of "other" or "unknown" co…

I never fill out the preferred pronoun section that have suddenly made their way into forms.

Isn't preferred pronouns kind of orthogonal to the rest of the stuff? It has nothing to do with attempting to ensure representation and is instead about addressing a person in the manner of their choosing, akin to asking a woman if she prefers Ms, Miss, Mme, Mrs, etc.

I expect it's probably way more appropriate in most contexts to directly ask a person what their preferred pronouns are than to ask what their gender identity is; the pronouns are what you actually need and this way you're finding them out with certainty rather than trying to guess based on some internal gender->pronoun mapping table.

Re: Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

#37
Left and liberal do not mean the same thing. Basically all of my blue or red friends agree with the principles of Liberalism, which brought us the enlightenment and [modern] civilization. You can ask your own friends, here's a definition:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberalism (quote below)

In terms of numbers, about 8% of the US population is.. left. 25% is traditional conservative. And the other 67% is regular folks who in fact agree on most policy questions

From Wikipedia:

> Liberalism is a political and moral philosophy based on liberty, consent of the governed and equality before the law. Liberals espouse a wide array of views depending on their understanding of these principles, but they generally support individual rights (including civil rights and human rights), democracy, secularism, freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of religion and a market economy

Re: Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

#38
post #22

I'm not sure these sorts of articles provide much value on HN. By "these sorts of articles", I mean the ones that have claimed that "diversity efforts have gone too far this time ." Regardless of your support or opposition to diversity, I think one would agree that these rapidly turn into unproductive, highly divisive comment sections that are out of place with the rest of HN.

You can use the flag button if you think that an article will attract low-quality discussion. I used to use it a lot. Be forewarned that your flags will stop influencing results if you use them too frequently, as I apparently did.

Re: Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

#39

What clearly seems wrong is the requirement to fill out forms on the race and gender of people you interview, and to have quotas to control whose voice is heard based on those irrelevant traits (irrelevant relative to the individual person's life, ideas, experiences, ability to express themselves etc.) My policy is to refuse to give my gender or race. If everybody did this, high frequencies of "other" or "unknown" co…

If asked for race, I suggest answering "human".

Re: Speaking Freely: Why I resigned from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

#40
>It is to become less adversarial to government and corporations and more hostile to ordinary people with ideas that Twitter doesn’t like.

as a regular reader of CBC, this is the line here that resonates the most with me. If CBC was a left-wing organization advocating for tearing down the structures of power and building a more equitable society, their focus on whatever microagression is currently trending would seem a lot more honest. but their bias is overwhelmingly in favour of the governments and corporations who have built the status quo, so their articles decrying social inequities ring pretty hollow.

Post reply on HN