Live data from Hacker News

Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

thehindu.com

31–40 of 279 posts

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#31
Despite a lot of investigation it looks like Fukushima did not cause an increase in cancer deaths (and there were no direct deaths from it either).

It's sad and strange that we treat it as if it had caused hundreds or thousands of deaths, and our response to it is to increase fossil fuel use, which definitely will lead to more death and pollution.

Read for yourself https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_nuclear_disaster

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#32
post #25
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is amazing. But two major incidents within 30 years time range are not so amazing. When we continue in that rate we will have a serious problem. And with aging reactors and instability everywhere it does not look good.

One incident caused by a natural disaster that would never happen in a European country like Germany, the other caused by mismanagement and frankly jaw droppingly pigheaded incompetence which would also never happen in a country like Germany. Edit: in response to the large number of people bringing up BER and other infrastructure failures in Germany: yes, BER and others may have been bad, but a completely different k…

Yes, although never say never...

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#33

I live in Germany and I wonder, what the consequences will be of shutting down both coal and nuclear in very short time. My guess is, we will pay for nuclear energy from France and coal energy from Poland when wind slows down. The new government tries to accelerate the construction of renewable energy but I think their plans will fail because of worker shortage and supply chain problems.

Yup, and we will end up paying 50% more for our energy usage, just because of political swings.

Avoiding nuclear will save you money in the long run though

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#34
post #23

I live in Germany and I wonder, what the consequences will be of shutting down both coal and nuclear in very short time. My guess is, we will pay for nuclear energy from France and coal energy from Poland when wind slows down. The new government tries to accelerate the construction of renewable energy but I think their plans will fail because of worker shortage and supply chain problems.

Shutting down nuclear to buy coal sounds pretty countereffective. What was the justification for this decision?

Fukushima.

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#35
post #23

I live in Germany and I wonder, what the consequences will be of shutting down both coal and nuclear in very short time. My guess is, we will pay for nuclear energy from France and coal energy from Poland when wind slows down. The new government tries to accelerate the construction of renewable energy but I think their plans will fail because of worker shortage and supply chain problems.

Shutting down nuclear to buy coal sounds pretty countereffective. What was the justification for this decision?

No one decided to do this, it's just OP's predictions. OP might turn out to be wrong. Or right...

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#36

Yeah, this has been known for a long time now that Germany is planning to shut down their nuclear plants. I have no clue why. There is a country in Eastern Europe and >60% of their electricity is from their nuclear power plants, and they are extending it. Imagine this country exporting electricity to Germany. Anyways, I believe it was a pretty shitty idea to say no to nuclear.

[deleted]

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#37
post #20

To be replaced by Russian gas. Great move!

Yeah, I'm a supporter of Nordstream 2 because cheap gas is better than expensive gas, but I can't understand why Germany is making itself more dependent on gas instead of building out nuclear capacity to be less dependent.

The whole policy really doesn't make a lot of sense, it's not pro-fossil fuel or anti-fossil fuel, it's not pro-Russia or anti-Russia. It's all of the above, which is worse, since it's anti-everything and pro-everything. It suggests German leadership is too incompetent to pursue their own interests and so they are effectively acting randomly.

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#39
post #23

I live in Germany and I wonder, what the consequences will be of shutting down both coal and nuclear in very short time. My guess is, we will pay for nuclear energy from France and coal energy from Poland when wind slows down. The new government tries to accelerate the construction of renewable energy but I think their plans will fail because of worker shortage and supply chain problems.

Shutting down nuclear to buy coal sounds pretty countereffective. What was the justification for this decision?

Nuclear is "bad" and scary... Plus you know nuclear weapons. And solar and wind produce plenty... Apart form times when they do not, like many times during winter.

Re: Germany shuts down half of its remaining nuclear plants

#40

Nuclear power is an amazing energy source. It doesn’t look like we’ll ever get beyond the politics that would make small scale It’s really a shame.

It's not politics. It is a practical reality that it is dangerous. As dangerous as coal plants. But for some reason HN likes to turn a blind eye to un-disposable toxic waste and the potential for citywide devastation (Chernobyl).
Post reply on HN