Live data from Hacker News

GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

rscott.org

21–30 of 89 posts

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#21

What do you guys use instead of GoDaddy? Just interested to see what others prefer out there. I was gonna do a domain transfer to GoDaddy, but after reading this I won't be considering them.

I've used 1and1.com for years and they are almost always cheaper than godaddy.

Watch out: 1and1 might not be quite as bad as godaddy in some of their policies, but they are very close. Avoid if at all possible.

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#22

What do you guys use instead of GoDaddy? Just interested to see what others prefer out there. I was gonna do a domain transfer to GoDaddy, but after reading this I won't be considering them.

I've used 1and1.com for years and they are almost always cheaper than godaddy.

[deleted]

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#23
post #10
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you use GoDaddy your sites may not work because GoDaddy is too cheap to provision enough servers to handle the load. So don't use GoDaddy.

Lets not over-sensationalize this, buy domains from GoDaddy, just skip the other services. Their domains and SSL certs are still some of the cheapest.

Godaddy SSL cert: $50

Namecheap SSL cert (RapidSSL): $10

StartCom SSL cert: $0

Gandi.net SSL cert: $0 with domain registration

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#24

What do you guys use instead of GoDaddy? Just interested to see what others prefer out there. I was gonna do a domain transfer to GoDaddy, but after reading this I won't be considering them.

I transferred from GoDaddy to name.com about a year ago by recommendation of a friend. It's nice to not be bombarded with GD babes and just enter my account to do what I need to do.

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#25

No major DNS provider would engage in a "Selective DNS Blackout" because of resource constraints - DNS is one of those protocols that is both embarrassingly parallel, as well as super efficient to serve. It's not unreasonable to see a well tuned, inexpensive ( This article doesn't pass the common sense test. Not to say that GoDaddy isn't engaging in this selective DNS blackout policy, just that it's not because of a…

Maybe the article has been changed but it indeed says that it most likely not about cost but about pushing a 'premium' dns service.

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#26

What do you guys use instead of GoDaddy? Just interested to see what others prefer out there. I was gonna do a domain transfer to GoDaddy, but after reading this I won't be considering them.

I transferred from GoDaddy to name.com about a year ago by recommendation of a friend. It's nice to not be bombarded with GD babes and just enter my account to do what I need to do.

I use godaddy to just do what I want, and really like the ui. Maybe I just know where to click but I'm not bombarded by anything.

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#27
I moved away from GoDaddy years ago. They have proven themselves to be irrationally self-interested. This is just one more reason no one should use them. While the domain cost is low, ancillary costs are high: not to mention moral cost for using a company that kills Elephants for sport.

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#28
post #25

No major DNS provider would engage in a "Selective DNS Blackout" because of resource constraints - DNS is one of those protocols that is both embarrassingly parallel, as well as super efficient to serve. It's not unreasonable to see a well tuned, inexpensive ( This article doesn't pass the common sense test. Not to say that GoDaddy isn't engaging in this selective DNS blackout policy, just that it's not because of a…

Maybe the article has been changed but it indeed says that it most likely not about cost but about pushing a 'premium' dns service.

That makes a lot more sense. It would be a lot better if the DNS provider said something like, "First million DNS entries served is free, after that, we charge you $0.50/million queries" (Amazon pricing for DNS)

Then, you respond to every request as fast as you can. (Note, this also provides an incentive to the customer to jack up the TTL on the resource records, so 99.99% of the requests are handled at the caching servers instead of GoDaddy)

Re: GoDaddy's New "Selective DNS Blackouts" Policy

#29
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've used 1and1.com for years and they are almost always cheaper than godaddy.

Watch out: 1and1 might not be quite as bad as godaddy in some of their policies, but they are very close. Avoid if at all possible.

Care to explain in more detail? (I moved from GoDaddy to 1&1 a few months back)
Post reply on HN