Live data from Hacker News

Against 3x Speed

perell.com

61–70 of 353 posts

Re: Against 3x Speed

#61
I watch everything I can in 2x speed, except for exceptionally fast talkers (those I watch on 1.5x, usually).

I think I could go up to 2.5x speed, but most video sites do not provide an option for that.

1x is just too slow.

And yes, I get everything at 2x. Not everyone can. I know one person with an auditory processing disorder who cannot manage even 1.5x without a lot of effort. I suspect handling 2x is partly about skill, but not entirely.

Re: Against 3x Speed

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which addon are you using for youtube?

I just modify it directly in the console (I have to search to look up the command every time).

Hit the Up arrow key in the console; in Firefox at least, command history persists across sessions.

For reference; $('video').playbackRate=3.33

The playback engine mutes audio below 0.25x and above 4x, not configurable.

Re: Against 3x Speed

#63
post #4

I get the point you're making - but honestly I have to raise the counter argument, which I think is equally valid. Take for example, the average lecture video. The information density is so low, that I'd imagine that a 60 minute video could be compressed into 10-12 minutes without any loss of information. It really depends on what you're listening to/watching.

It's not just density, many books are pure nonsense. So 200 books of pure nonsense a year won't teach you much. They'll just introduce you to a ton of terrible ideas.

Re: Against 3x Speed

#64
I watch my lectures at between 2x(math classes) and 3.5x(business classes) speed. Most professors just talk unconscionably slow, and done kitties focus in material so basic that I don't really have to understand every word.

Re: Against 3x Speed

#65

I'd argue that 95% of all learning, is learnt by doing. Merely listening to something without properly interrogating your understanding of it.. you will end up with a bunch of shallow and untested knowledge. At best, a boffin. It's imperative to build, discuss, interrogate, trial and fail.

I disagree, if you are just doing you won’t be learning new things. I work at a place where there a lot of of long-timers are there and at that time there were only people that can from different fields. Those people work since 10, 20 years without even mastering what they do. If they have to do something new they either give up or just try to come up with something on their own. Most of the time people have done thi…

You're right! I'd say doing is important for actually understanding and retaining information while reading is important for understanding the triumphs and failures of others and "stealing" ideas.

Interspersing the two is perhaps the best way of learning. For example you don't want to learn to swim by watching 12, hour-long videos on swimming techniques, costumes and its history. You do wanna watch a 15 minute instructions video on how to get your feet wet and then go ahead and actually get your feet wet and then come back and watch the next 15 minutes of video on how to step into the pool.

Re: Against 3x Speed

#66

I agree with other commenters: it's all about the content. I listen to most podcasts at 2x at least because they often are too much chatter or are repeating things I know. But sometimes I pause them to think when something new arises. In other cases, like some types of YouTube videos, I watch at 0.75x because they are way too fast and have no white-space, way too dense. And in all of this, the MAIN thing I learn is W…

It does depend on the content. Personally, if its for entertainment I default to x2 speed (thanks apple tv+ for including x2 speed instead of netflix's x1.5 half measure); but for educational purposes I go down to x1.5

The downside is, after a few days of getting used to it, x1 content feels like slow motion.

Re: Against 3x Speed

#67
The few podcasts I listen to, I do so in 0.2x speed or even less. Not by slowing the playback speed, obviously, but by pausing and rewinding very often to think about what has been said and even take notes if I find something that resonates with me.

Most podcasts though I listen to at infinite speed, meaning I don't listen to them at all. You can go through them 2-3x speed because there's really nothing there.

It's like code: if it's boilerplate you can just skim it but if it's really doing something you have to read it slowly multiple times. And just like the saying: nothing of value is easily gained.

If you find yourself speeding though things - in general, not just podcasts - I would ask myself if they're worth doing at all.

Re: Against 3x Speed

#68
The optimal speed very much content and goal dependent. Some narrators just speak slowly, some books are very information dense, and are you trying to memorise the entire book or just pick out a few points?

Re: Against 3x Speed

#69
Listening at 3x speed and concentrating deeply on the material =\= listening at 3x speed while trying to multitask

Most informative content is, I have observed, fairly slow and repetitious. This is a good way to produce content because it is fair to assume that most people will not be fully mentally engaged in what you’re trying to tell them. That’s not a bad thing - your audience may simply not understand the importance of what you’re trying to say until they’ve heard it once). However, viewers who want to fully engage with content may find themselves having trouble concentrating due to the slow speed of information.

Personally, I use 1x for most entertainment and for informative material if I’m doing some other activity like chores or driving, 2x for entertainment content which has a lot of fluff (e.g. pretty much everything on YouTube these days), and 2.5x for informative content which I am giving my full attention to (although I often pause to consider what’s been said or rewind to rewatch a dense portion of the content at a slower speed). That’s a pretty good balance for me.

Re: Against 3x Speed

#70
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I use the same youtube plugin mentioned in the article, and watch many videos at 2.5x-3.0x speed, for the exact reason that you state. There is a lot of "filler" content that I either a) already know or b) is not relevant to what I'm trying to learn. I'm really just trying to get through that content quickly. When I get to some really dense portion though, I will turn the speed down to 1x to learn it.

Which addon are you using for youtube?

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/youtube-playback-s...

But I suspect they're all mostly similar

Post reply on HN