Live data from Hacker News

If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

techdirt.com

81–90 of 116 posts

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why not just provide streaming versions for free, and insert new ads whenever they feel like it. It could even be like a website where a Person could find lots of different streaming video programs. I would use that in a heartbeat.

That already exists. It's called Hulu.

Not available in Europe either. But then I guess such a torrent solution would be ip limited to the US as well...

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can "buy" an episode of the Simpsons (SD) on amazon.com for $1.99, so that's probably a reasonable price.

Or you can watch it on broadcast TV in HD for 'free'.

I think I'd pay $0.05 to watch an episode of the Simpsons without ads.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#83

The giant elephant in the room is being overlooked: Advertisements have a lifespan measured in months, weeks, or days. Television content can stay relevant for decades. Imagine it's the year 1997. Aliens from the planet GNU have gone back in time and provided us with bittorrent, and technology making dial-up modems a million times faster (but they still drop their connection if your mom picks up the phone). You just…

I don't think it'd go to that extreme. Sure, the ads would be outdated, but the brands are still there. You're still exposed to the Apple brand, and are reminded that they've been (hypothetically) awesome since 1997 and beyond. You're still exposed to McDonald's and might head out for a Big Mac (I suspect that'll stay on forever). Maybe Volkswagens will get better in ten year's time ;-)

The problem is that no one is going to pay for you watching their ads in 10 years.

Ads are also really crafted at society at that given time. I heard a quote from a history professor who said he could teach American history using only Coca-Cola ads.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#84

Product Placement. Product Placement. Product Placement. Product Placement. Product Placement. Product Placement. I know it's kind of annoying/cheap sometimes when a camera zooms in on the Bud Light logo in a fridge, or when Don Draper says that he loves Smirnoff (lawl), but its the only choice that the studios have. They must turn to product placement as their primary source of advertising revenue. Because if they j…

Well that would be a good way to get me of watching new tv episodes, that is for sure.

I hate product placement because it breaks the story and my suspension of disbelief.

But hey, maybe I would get more done that way.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#86
No, I hate sitting through commercials. They also cheapen the medium and you'll note that premium networks generally have better shows. What I will do is pay a flat rate to get access to whatever content that provider has the rights to that I can watch whenever I want.

For reference, I would regard access to every television show ever produced and streamed reliably, at high definition when available, as worth $150-200/month.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#87
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think it'd go to that extreme. Sure, the ads would be outdated, but the brands are still there. You're still exposed to the Apple brand, and are reminded that they've been (hypothetically) awesome since 1997 and beyond. You're still exposed to McDonald's and might head out for a Big Mac (I suspect that'll stay on forever). Maybe Volkswagens will get better in ten year's time ;-)

The problem is that no one is going to pay for you watching their ads in 10 years. Ads are also really crafted at society at that given time. I heard a quote from a history professor who said he could teach American history using only Coca-Cola ads.

If that's the case, that's not really a problem. You get high ad exposure at the time of each episode's release, as many people will want to keep up with the show within the first few years of its airing. You're paying for their eyes.

Anyone watching it 10 years down the line is just icing on the cake for you, but that's not what you'd pay for in such a model.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#89

The giant elephant in the room is being overlooked: Advertisements have a lifespan measured in months, weeks, or days. Television content can stay relevant for decades. Imagine it's the year 1997. Aliens from the planet GNU have gone back in time and provided us with bittorrent, and technology making dial-up modems a million times faster (but they still drop their connection if your mom picks up the phone). You just…

They can easily release news, commentary and talk shows programs on the Internet, including as torrents, because their value decays exponentially once they're aired.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That already exists. It's called Hulu.

Not available in Europe either. But then I guess such a torrent solution would be ip limited to the US as well...

The American networks aren't exactly set up to sell advertising to all of the other 192 countries in the world...

Sure, there are a few global brands that might buy in anyway, but the advertising would be less targeted and there would be less competition for the same slots, so rates would be significantly lower while costs would stay the same (or even be higher.)

All this is ignoring the myriad existing deals that the networks have with peers in other contries offering exclusive region-wide access to certain content. Working around this would be possible, but would result in numerous IP blocks anyway.

Post reply on HN