Live data from Hacker News

If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

techdirt.com

11–20 of 116 posts

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#11

So long as the ads are a small portion of the video and the recording is high-quality, of course! I could probably even be talked into ignoring the equally high-quality rips without ads- I would love to encourage such a forward-thinking model. Now, if we're talking 10 minutes of content and 20 minutes of advertising,... no.

Also, the audio of the commercials shouldn't be louder than that of the content.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#12
I would, but unfortunately they'd never release torrents with ads unless they could stop you from skipping them.

The only way to do this would be a custom filetype and player, no? And the chances of of being able to stream that to your xbox or media player...

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#13
I guess one of the issues here is localisation. If you insert a commercial in a video then everyone, everywhere needs to watch that same commercial.

Also, commercials tend to go stale. You want to switch commercials based on season or even current affairs. This doesn't allow you to do that, T.V. and streaming video does.

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for it but I think these are two major issues potential advertisers will struggle with.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#14
I would watch streaming TV shows with targeted ads, but I don't think I would download a TV show with generic ads. If there's an advertisement before a YouTube video plays, I'll avoid watching it, but if it means that I can watch a TV show without paying $2-3 per episode, I'd feel a lot warmer about the idea.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#17
I live in Europe, but absolutely "need" to watch American television. My only option is Hulu via a US VPN or Usenet. Currently, I choose the Usenet route. I would be glad to pay for some 3rd option. I have disposable income to give away, but if giving it to you is worse than my 2nd best option, you lose.

I just forked over nearly $100 today to buy access to Big Ten Network live streaming of football games for the 2011-2012 season. I did this because I need this access and there was no better option. There were free options, trust me, a little googling and I can get any NCAA football game for free, but Big Ten offered the best quality of service at a great price.

Regular TV. Why can't you learn from the football guys? I honestly have no idea how to access American broadcast TV from Europe. Outside of waiting 20 years for reruns of Twin Peaks to appear on basic cable.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#18
post #16

I can see the message already: "The torrent you're trying to download is not available in your country" Thank you content industry...

This. But if they didn't do that, I totally would download them.

The advertising has to be short and not take up a huge portion of the video. Also, smartphone and tablet compatible formats, please.

Re: If TV Companies Released Authorized Torrents With Ads, Would You Download Them?

#19
I have an honest question why should I pay when the product they are offering is inferior in every way to the setup I have been using for the last 2-3 years? For the past few years I have used a irssi script that is setup with the tv shows that I want to download and the quality i wish to have them downloaded in this takes about 5 minutes to setup and about the same to maintain every season after this five minute time investment I’m getting shows less then a half an hour after they air on the east coast in 720p with no commercials that means when I’m ready to watch them that night or later that year they are ready to go with no hassle no worrying about whether or not its on netflix or waiting a week to see it on hulu if i want to see breaking bad i can watch it 15 mins after its done airing on the east coast and be done before its even done airing in Texas until they can offer up something to match that I don’t see any reason to meet them half way.
Post reply on HN