Live data from Hacker News

Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

reuters.com

21–30 of 262 posts

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#21
post #4

Quoted post unavailable.

1. Force people into draconian measures that won't stop infection and violate their rights. 2. Convince them that it's necessary to stop the pandemic without giving any arguments. 3. Have them defend your measures in public forums and feel very smart.

[deleted]

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#22
post #5
post #3

We were promised this wouldn't happen by our governments last year right? It feels like the public are building their own prisons. Why are private companies stuck policing these absurd policies?

Unless you have medical exemption, it's just a jab in the arm?

For many people, it's more than just a jab, it's 1-3 days of being quite unwell.

I have no underlying health conditions, but I've been bedridden by my 2nd shot and booster shots, with a high fever, fatigue, dizziness, and aches for at least 48 hours. My partner who is immuno-compromised is worse off, generally being very ill for 1-2 weeks after each jab. Her case is somewhat different though, as her situation is just all round unfortunate.

I'm not saying I won't continue to comply with all health advisories for vaccination or other public safety measures, and I'm not saying vaccines aren't worth it for society. But it's not "just" a jab.

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#23
post #9
post #6

This is just life, forever. Totally unprecedented. You will get a vaccination every 6 months for the rest of your life or be totally excluded from all civil rights. There will be no end. If the virus mutates to become harmless, the mandates will be given all the credit, and we will double down on this system. It's not temporary.

What about the rights of a private (in the sense of government) company to make their own decisions?

Google is free to set their rules and we are free to complain about them.

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#24
post #19
post #6

This is just life, forever. Totally unprecedented. You will get a vaccination every 6 months for the rest of your life or be totally excluded from all civil rights. There will be no end. If the virus mutates to become harmless, the mandates will be given all the credit, and we will double down on this system. It's not temporary.

> This is just life, forever. Totally unprecedented. You will get a vaccination every 6 months for the rest of your life or be totally excluded from all civil rights. “all civil rights” meaning you have full civil rights but can't force a private company to give you a job when you refuse to follow safety rules? Especially in a country where employers pay for healthcare it doesn't seem unreasonable to require a safe,…

If we eventually define "civil rights" to mean "you have the right to stay inside your home and order everything on Amazon", we have a serious problem. That's where this is going. It goes way beyond the decisions of an individual company.

Regarding the status quo: Yes, mandates exist. The school example is a piece of paper you turn into the school office during enrollment and no one ever thinks about it again. It's not a status tracked in real time, apps don't have to be presented to enter buildings. And in most cases, people can file for exemptions if it really matters to them.

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#25
post #8
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless you have medical exemption, it's just a jab in the arm?

It's capitulation to coercion, which has its own side effects.

At my restaurant we save money by never cleaning the kitchen. No one should coerce me into doing something where it is not necessary. Cleaning wastes my time and money and it's my freedom to not clean! No one should take that freedom away in a free country!

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#26
post #6

This is just life, forever. Totally unprecedented. You will get a vaccination every 6 months for the rest of your life or be totally excluded from all civil rights. There will be no end. If the virus mutates to become harmless, the mandates will be given all the credit, and we will double down on this system. It's not temporary.

> be totally excluded from all civil rights

You don't have a civil right to employment at Google.

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#27
post #4

Quoted post unavailable.

1. Force people into draconian measures that won't stop infection and violate their rights. 2. Convince them that it's necessary to stop the pandemic without giving any arguments. 3. Have them defend your measures in public forums and feel very smart.

> violate their rights

Citation needed.

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#28
post #20
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about the rights of a private (in the sense of government) company to make their own decisions?

I don't believe in the rights of private companies to do just anything they want to workers. Most people don't - look at the popularity of indoor smoking bans. Most also agree a private business shouldn't be allowed to deny employment or service based on race. There are many, many such examples.

Are you really claiming an indoor smoking ban is a counter example to a vaccine mandiate? That's some interesting logic.

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#29
post #6

This is just life, forever. Totally unprecedented. You will get a vaccination every 6 months for the rest of your life or be totally excluded from all civil rights. There will be no end. If the virus mutates to become harmless, the mandates will be given all the credit, and we will double down on this system. It's not temporary.

You are free to not work at Google, and you are free to not take part in society if you dont wish to participate in the societal contract.

Re: Google says employees flouting vaccination rules will eventually be fired

#30
post #9
post #6

This is just life, forever. Totally unprecedented. You will get a vaccination every 6 months for the rest of your life or be totally excluded from all civil rights. There will be no end. If the virus mutates to become harmless, the mandates will be given all the credit, and we will double down on this system. It's not temporary.

What about the rights of a private (in the sense of government) company to make their own decisions?

What about the rights of a private company to discriminate based on ethnicity, religion, disability, gender, etc?
Post reply on HN