Live data from Hacker News

Tacit knowledge is more important than deliberate practice

commoncog.com

131–133 of 133 posts

Re: Tacit knowledge is more important than deliberate practice

#131
The title reads like a category error. Yes, expertise consists of tacit knowledge, but that doesn't tell you anything about whether deliberate practice is the way to acquire it or not. It only tells you that memorizing text won't get you there. To the extent that it's not a category error, it's a tautology: arriving at the office is more important than driving to the office, making a milkshake is more important than running the blender, and acquiring expertise is more important than any particular technique you might use to acquire expertise.

At the bottom Chin says what he thinks is the way to acquire tacit knowledge: apprenticeship. He should have called the article "Apprenticeship is more important than deliberate practice," which hinges on precisely what you mean by "apprenticeship" and "deliberate practice," either of which can be defined in ways to make the statement true or false.

Re: Tacit knowledge is more important than deliberate practice

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Without that we suffer when we get advice like "be yourself", "read Dale Carnegie", etc. I've grown to appreciate such useless advice. It is useless in answering the question you wanted help with but it is a strong signal that you can prune the person who gave such advice out of your social graph without any negative repercussions.

Couldn't you argue the person you would be pruning is a person that is most likely to appreciate you just as you are? It seems reasonable to argue that if they are indeed in your social graph and they give you that advice, perhaps they like you for who you are and thus the advice at least from their perspective is good.

Making an absolute was overstating my case. In the good faith scenario, the other person does appreciate you as you are. Not so worth it to burn that relationship. Probably wise to make a mental note not to ask them for advice, assuming your goal was for more than being accepted by the person you just asked for advice.

Re: Tacit knowledge is more important than deliberate practice

#133
post #92
post #2

"he calls it “the ability to create great art or assess a startup (…) " Milan, 1496: "Hey Leonardo, I really like your last supper, great work. Oh, and hey by the way, your assement of the new company was awesome"

lol, I'm not surprised that this is the most downvoted reply here, nor am I surprised that it's a good one.

The rules of HN do a good job of keeping topics on topic and informative, but sometimes sterilise it of genius like this. Oh well, some things are worth taking downvotes for.
Post reply on HN