Live data from Hacker News

Assange judge is 40-year ‘good friend’ of minister who orchestrated his arrest

declassifieduk.org

1–10 of 82 posts

Re: Assange judge is 40-year ‘good friend’ of minister who orchestrated his arrest

#3
Most voices in support of Assange seem to come from people with strong conviction that he is clearly a good guy (unsurprisingly). I don’t really have an opinion.

Could someone provide a more impassioned / balanced list of pros and cons?

From my vague point of view, I get that he is sort of a journalist (so should be protected), but also the stuff he leaked did go quite far, like borderline-espionage scale (or is that unfair?). States have a reasonable need to keep things secret, even against the immediate best interest of the citizens (but not long term, clearly). Is much known about his associates, funding sources? If I were an enemy of the USA I’d probably quite like Assange (not that this on its own makes Assange himself a bad guy).

Could someone fill in the gaps ELI5?

Re: Assange judge is 40-year ‘good friend’ of minister who orchestrated his arrest

#5

Most voices in support of Assange seem to come from people with strong conviction that he is clearly a good guy (unsurprisingly). I don’t really have an opinion. Could someone provide a more impassioned / balanced list of pros and cons? From my vague point of view, I get that he is sort of a journalist (so should be protected), but also the stuff he leaked did go quite far, like borderline-espionage scale (or is that…

impassioned (comparative more impassioned, superlative most impassioned)

    Filled with intense emotion or passion; fervent.
Perhaps you meant "impartial"?

Re: Assange judge is 40-year ‘good friend’ of minister who orchestrated his arrest

#6

Most voices in support of Assange seem to come from people with strong conviction that he is clearly a good guy (unsurprisingly). I don’t really have an opinion. Could someone provide a more impassioned / balanced list of pros and cons? From my vague point of view, I get that he is sort of a journalist (so should be protected), but also the stuff he leaked did go quite far, like borderline-espionage scale (or is that…

This is a good read: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/21839908-when-google-met...

Re: Assange judge is 40-year ‘good friend’ of minister who orchestrated his arrest

#7

Most voices in support of Assange seem to come from people with strong conviction that he is clearly a good guy (unsurprisingly). I don’t really have an opinion. Could someone provide a more impassioned / balanced list of pros and cons? From my vague point of view, I get that he is sort of a journalist (so should be protected), but also the stuff he leaked did go quite far, like borderline-espionage scale (or is that…

There’s no universe in which Assange deserves the treatment he would receive in the US no matter how bad of a guy he is.

Re: Assange judge is 40-year ‘good friend’ of minister who orchestrated his arrest

#8
post #5

Most voices in support of Assange seem to come from people with strong conviction that he is clearly a good guy (unsurprisingly). I don’t really have an opinion. Could someone provide a more impassioned / balanced list of pros and cons? From my vague point of view, I get that he is sort of a journalist (so should be protected), but also the stuff he leaked did go quite far, like borderline-espionage scale (or is that…

impassioned (comparative more impassioned, superlative most impassioned) Filled with intense emotion or passion; fervent. Perhaps you meant "impartial"?

Probably "impassionate". (Which has been displaced in modern usage by "dispassionate", but if you learned your English from books you're likely to still use.)

Re: Assange judge is 40-year ‘good friend’ of minister who orchestrated his arrest

#9
post #7

Most voices in support of Assange seem to come from people with strong conviction that he is clearly a good guy (unsurprisingly). I don’t really have an opinion. Could someone provide a more impassioned / balanced list of pros and cons? From my vague point of view, I get that he is sort of a journalist (so should be protected), but also the stuff he leaked did go quite far, like borderline-espionage scale (or is that…

There’s no universe in which Assange deserves the treatment he would receive in the US no matter how bad of a guy he is.

But there's a special place in earth where it routinely happens: the US of A.

What Assange is suffering pales against what happened in Guantanamo or Abu Ghraib.

Nobody ever paid.

Re: Assange judge is 40-year ‘good friend’ of minister who orchestrated his arrest

#10

Most voices in support of Assange seem to come from people with strong conviction that he is clearly a good guy (unsurprisingly). I don’t really have an opinion. Could someone provide a more impassioned / balanced list of pros and cons? From my vague point of view, I get that he is sort of a journalist (so should be protected), but also the stuff he leaked did go quite far, like borderline-espionage scale (or is that…

"help I need hacker news to tell me what to think"
Post reply on HN