Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 165 posts

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#71
I wish so much I could simply pay for ad-free versions of software, and I don't mean in-app purchases to unlock features, which I wish people didn't do and instead had a paid version in the store.

I use f-droid as much as possible, but there are a few things not available there.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#72
post #31

Good? What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free". Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

What information folks are allowed to supply is distinct from ensuring its accuracy, I think. Misleading app names are a problem regardless, but given that many apps have ads and charge for the ad-free experience, it seems odd the developer isn't allowed to highlight that in the title.

But Google can do as they wish: another reason alternative app stores have an important role to play.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> should be part of the store's listing - not the title. How long has Google store been operating (under various names)? Over a decade I think. Do they know people would love to choose between apps with and without ads? Of course. Why they decided not to implement it in the listing? Because they live from ads. There is exactly zero chance they will do it as you propose.

They've shown whether an app has ads for over five years: https://www.androidpolice.com/2016/04/28/the-play-store-star...

They won't have my appreciation or respect until they let me permanently filter out paid or adware apps and keep them filtered out until I choose to see them again.

It would be so easy to implement, it seems scornful not to. When I want a needle, they hand me a haystack and say "we etched 'this is a needle' into the needles for you so you'll know when you find one. Good luck."

I admit I haven't used android for three or four years so maybe they have this capability now, would love to be corrected if so.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title. ???? Did I miss the part where Google announced they were adding searchable metadata at the same time they eliminated adding this info to the title? If not, seems like a clearly anti-consumer move.

Listings show whether they have ads, in-app purchases etc. on a separate screen

Searching 'no ads' seemingly won't query that tag, seemingly.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"No ads" isn't editorializing, though. Unlike "best" or "#1", it's a statement of fact, and a fact that is probably useful to shoppers.

Could this be in response to apps indicating that they don't have ads even though they do?

That or the fact that google massively profits off the presence of ads in mobile apps.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#76
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Buy Uncle Miller’s Corn Flakes — 100% arsenic free!

Exactly. Another textbook example is the language describing meat as coming from pork with “no hormones added” even though it’s unlawful to add hormones to pork grown for human consumption. Sure, it’s a fact; but the choice to include it is made to provide a marketing boost over competing brands that might not have the language on the packaging.

Wow, that's incredibly dishonest to consumers! My turkey states "no hormones added," I assume that's also unlawful like pork?

It should be illegal to advertise you're not doing something that is illegal in the first place if the intent is to imply others are in fact doing it.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#77
I am an Android user fed up with Google, but I've never really focused on alternatives to stock Android. I briefly investigated Cyanogenmod and its successor, LineageOS, but never to the point of installing it. I do use the Gmail app on my phone, but it's not a requirement for me. Beyond that, I don't really have strong ties to the Google Suite of apps. I do have a few apps I've purchased and use frequently, but most are freeware.

All that said, for those of you who have de-Googled your phone, how much friction was there? Is there a leader of the pack for alternate app stores (if necessary), and/or do you load APKs directly?

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#78
This is frustrating.

One of my wife's favorite apps, Instagram's Boomerang, has been broken on Android 12 since release. No sign of fixing it. The app store has been flooded with 1 and 2 star reviews as a result. I went digging for an alternative. It's just playing a 5 second loop forwards and backwards, so it can't be hard to re-implement, right? Someone's gotta have an alternative.

You have now entered the Clone Wars. Dozens of imitation apps that claim to do the same, with similar names, touting similar features. Except they are riddled with ads and often don't even do what's advertised without some big watermark or outright paying for it. I'd love to find the one that's ad-free and just does what it should but I'm wading through what looks like aisles of a dollar store. The curation has gone to hell and this isn't helping. We need better ways of sorting and filtering on the app store.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the problem i faced is that aurora store is disliked by google and my account was terminated. would recommend though.

Your google account was terminated because you installed a different app store on your phone?

If I remember correctly, Aurora recommends signing into the app with a burner Google account in case of issues like this. I think Google's problem is not so much installing a different app store, but signing into your Google account from it.

Re: Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's title

#80
post #31

Good? What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free". Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

> Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title. ???? Did I miss the part where Google announced they were adding searchable metadata at the same time they eliminated adding this info to the title? If not, seems like a clearly anti-consumer move.

App titles not being filled with a bunch of promo crap sounds pretty pro-consumer to me

"It is what it says on the tin"

Post reply on HN