Live data from Hacker News

New Zealand plans to make it illegal for kids to buy cigarettes – for life

cbc.ca

1–10 of 162 posts

Re: New Zealand plans to make it illegal for kids to buy cigarettes – for life

#5
Sidestepping questions of personal freedom, I think the method here is interesting. No one will have their access to buy cigarettes taken away. Some people will never receive the access in the first place. It’s easier to not grant access than to grant it, then take it away. I wonder if this could have other legal applications.

Re: New Zealand plans to make it illegal for kids to buy cigarettes – for life

#9
I fully support this, but sadly there will be kids to whom possession and the smoking of cigarettes will be even more a sign of the utmost coolness. And, as I understand it there will be a time when a 35 year old can buy cigarettes but a 34 year old can't. That's going to be interesting.

Re: New Zealand plans to make it illegal for kids to buy cigarettes – for life

#10
post #5

Sidestepping questions of personal freedom, I think the method here is interesting. No one will have their access to buy cigarettes taken away. Some people will never receive the access in the first place. It’s easier to not grant access than to grant it, then take it away. I wonder if this could have other legal applications.

I fully support the spirit of this legislation, because I'm a recovered nicotine addict and I wish I had never been granted access to nicotine when I first experimented with it.

> Some people will never receive the access in the first place

This simply isn't true. People will purchase nicotine from older people, while that's still possible, and then there will be a blossoming bootleg nicotine market.

We've seen prohibition fail enough times to know that it simply doesn't work.

Post reply on HN