Live data from Hacker News

You can't google 9999999..99999999999999999999999

google.com

1–10 of 84 posts

Re: You can't google 9999999..99999999999999999999999

#4
On a faintly related note, I once was calculating partitions, using a relatively inefficient method (memoization: if f(n,k) is the number of distinct ways to express n as the unordered sum of integers no greater than k, then f(n,k) = f(n-k,k) + f(n,k-1)). My computer started to feel the strain in the thousands (this algorithm is O(n^2) in space and time). I then googled for the partition of, say, 1034, which is:

  91363785902248291467082481888195
I figured that chances are that no website will have that integer on there by accident. Lo and behold, I found, among other results, a text file containing the partitions up to 10,000, presumably done with a more efficient algorithm (likely Euler's ridiculous pentagonal-number recurrence formula, which, memoized, is roughly O(n^1.5) in time and O(n) in space): http://oeis.org/A000041/b000041.txt

Re: You can't google 9999999..99999999999999999999999

#5

Can someone please explain me why that happens? Google says - "Our systems have detected unusual traffic from your computer network. Please try your request again later."

Do you regularly search for 99999...999999? Sounds like it's unusual to me!

Re: You can't google 9999999..99999999999999999999999

#6

Can someone please explain me why that happens? Google says - "Our systems have detected unusual traffic from your computer network. Please try your request again later."

It seems to slow down, as you increase from:

111..111 11111..111111

and eventually crashes.

I'm guessing there is some kind of grammar parser breaking horribly. There's grammar parsers that have extremely poor performance trying to parse stuff that looks like this. It might do:

search 1 and 111111..11111

search 11 and 11111..11111

...

search 1 and 1 and 11111..111

...

...

...

and google detects that you are DOSing its server.

OK, someone else has pointed out that this is a range search, and google may be protecting CC searches.

Re: You can't google 9999999..99999999999999999999999

#7

Can someone please explain me why that happens? Google says - "Our systems have detected unusual traffic from your computer network. Please try your request again later."

Years ago somebody discovered you could Google for credit card numbers that had been left on the web inadvertently, by searching for the right number range. I wonder if that is why it is unavailable.

Re: You can't google 9999999..99999999999999999999999

#10
The reason for this is that you can google ranges of numbers, and people a couple of years ago were using this feature to find credit card numbers that were posted online, eg searching for 4000000000000000..4999999999999999

It was around the time that johnny's google hacking page became popular, iirc. (http://www.hackersforcharity.org/ghdb/)

Post reply on HN