Live data from Hacker News

MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

mikrotik.com

21–30 of 188 posts

Re: MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

#21

I've been thinking about going with Mikrotik at least twice but never pulled the trigger because I am sort of a chicken shit. Is it easy for a noob to setup things like port forwarding and vlans on a router/ap box?

worked for me. one suggestion though, get a serial cable, so in case you creative some too creative vlan config that will lock you out, you could fix it without having to reset entire box

Re: MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

#22

I would really like to see a open source alternative that can interface with all sorts of different hardware to manage my infrastructure with a single pane of glass. Sorta Ubiquti - but leveraging things like the Unifi API & the new REST api on Microtek to get me out of vendor lock in. I don't think I have ever seen anything along those lines out there. Im actually happy with my unifi setup - but there are some thing…

There is some OS tooling in the SDN realm, like Stratum[1] for example, or a P4 board for the serious. But the hardware behind it isn't cheap.

I wish router for personal use were as "easily" programmable as an OpenFlow compatible equipment with a external controller. Even if you need some extra tooling to reach all the feature of RouterOS, like a compute node for the DNS. I don't know if this kind of evolution will ever reach the consumer space.

[1] https://opennetworking.org/stratum/

Re: MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

#23

Does MikroTik live in the same prosumer space that made ubiquiti products so popular early on?

Yes, but possibly with more ambition to be a budget alternative to Cisco and Juniper. Looking at the presentations under https://mum.mikrotik.com/, it seems there are quite a few ISPs running on MikroTik kit, especially in less-developed parts of the world.

Re: MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

#26

Does MikroTik live in the same prosumer space that made ubiquiti products so popular early on?

I just bought a bunch of Ubiquiti equipment (UDM Pro + 10G Switch Aggregate + U6-LR AP) and I've been super happy with it. Putting sexy UI aside, the performance is outstanding and rock solid.

Unifi really does unify the entire ecosystem, it's basically the Apple of network gear down the quality of packging. I love it.

I heard good things about Mikrotik but their product line feels scattered and unorganized.

Re: MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

#27
So, what's the best wifi gateway with extra access points for a home that I don't have to screw with and doesn't spy on me or have cloud crap? My ISP sent a Google wifi thing but I'd rather pay a few hundred than use that for 10 bucks a month to rent that thing, and I don't trust Google.

Edit: Thanks for all the answers, from me and anyone else who was looking! I have some good ideas from the below comments and hopefully this thread helps some others as well.

Re: MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

#28

I've been thinking about going with Mikrotik at least twice but never pulled the trigger because I am sort of a chicken shit. Is it easy for a noob to setup things like port forwarding and vlans on a router/ap box?

I've been using a MikroTik router at home for 6+ years; I would say that RouterOS is absolutely NOT "easy for a noob". It's on the prosumer side of things, but you need to be willing to sink your teeth into some fairly gritty network configuration workflows.

Anyone posting on HN will likely be able to figure out the basics, but it is definitely much less polished than other prosumer products such as Ubiquiti and the documentation can be a little rough around the edges.

Re: MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

#29

I've been thinking about going with Mikrotik at least twice but never pulled the trigger because I am sort of a chicken shit. Is it easy for a noob to setup things like port forwarding and vlans on a router/ap box?

Both the GUI and their CLI are among the most unintuitive systems I've ever seen. I definitely spent more than one evening trying to configure my Mikrotik from scratch as a typical home router + switch + AP. I'm no networking guru, I only did some Cisco stuff a few years ago at uni, but I didn't understand 80 % of the terms used in their OS.

Re: MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released

#30
post #27

So, what's the best wifi gateway with extra access points for a home that I don't have to screw with and doesn't spy on me or have cloud crap? My ISP sent a Google wifi thing but I'd rather pay a few hundred than use that for 10 bucks a month to rent that thing, and I don't trust Google. Edit: Thanks for all the answers, from me and anyone else who was looking! I have some good ideas from the below comments and hopef…

I use an Edgerouter-x with an eap225 AP located centrally. I have not noticed any spying.
Post reply on HN