Live data from Hacker News

Researchers shrink camera to the size of a salt grain

engineering.princeton.edu

101–105 of 105 posts

Re: Researchers shrink camera to the size of a salt grain

#101
post #6

That guy Felix Heide is a research powerhouse. He and his group published 4 papers in SIGGRAPH 21, 7 papers in CVPR 21 and 6 papers in CVPR 2020, wow. https://www.cs.princeton.edu/~fheide/

I know nothing of his work, and he may well be an excellent researcher, but the use of “number of papers published” as a proxy for the quality of someone’s research is one of the biggest problems in academia. What matters is the precise nature of a researcher’s work, which is a qualitative measure that cannot be summarised with a simplistic metric. It’s so odd that we even discuss such things; it’s an overused analog…

I agree partially, but SIGGRAPH and CVPR are highly regarded and aren't known to accept crappy work. There are some "soft" sub-fields of CS that can be a wash, like HCI and Software Engineering. Those fields have relied more and more on "marketability" of ideas instead of depth of technical contribution. But top conferences in fields like graphics and programming languages (POPL, PLDI) are no joke, you will not be able to get a paper that isn't top-notch into those confs.

Re: Researchers shrink camera to the size of a salt grain

#102
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think you are completly wrong. For instance, last year there was a whole debacle at one of those top conferences because someone from nvidia, that was in the board of this conference, made (and posted on twitter!) a black list for people who said something that was not alligned with hers ideology. (I wonder what happened after the whole thing went quiet). Yet, I do still think those conference, and their spon…

What exactly was the sort of stuff people are blacklisted for? It could be claiming that racial segregation is a great thing (which should be shunned and kept away) or it could be supporting multivitamin consumption (for which it seems like an overreach).

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25597008

The twitter thread https://web.archive.org/web/20201215001433/https://twitter.c...

Re: Researchers shrink camera to the size of a salt grain

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know nothing of his work, and he may well be an excellent researcher, but the use of “number of papers published” as a proxy for the quality of someone’s research is one of the biggest problems in academia. What matters is the precise nature of a researcher’s work, which is a qualitative measure that cannot be summarised with a simplistic metric. It’s so odd that we even discuss such things; it’s an overused analog…

I agree partially, but SIGGRAPH and CVPR are highly regarded and aren't known to accept crappy work. There are some "soft" sub-fields of CS that can be a wash, like HCI and Software Engineering. Those fields have relied more and more on "marketability" of ideas instead of depth of technical contribution. But top conferences in fields like graphics and programming languages (POPL, PLDI) are no joke, you will not be ab…

Don’t want to talk about specific conferences or individuals but I agree that some conferences (really, a handful) have far less of this problem than others.

Re: Researchers shrink camera to the size of a salt grain

#104
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What exactly was the sort of stuff people are blacklisted for? It could be claiming that racial segregation is a great thing (which should be shunned and kept away) or it could be supporting multivitamin consumption (for which it seems like an overreach).

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25597008 The twitter thread https://web.archive.org/web/20201215001433/https://twitter.c...

I cannot find anything on what was done except shunning neonazis. Is that the extent?

Re: Researchers shrink camera to the size of a salt grain

#105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25597008 The twitter thread https://web.archive.org/web/20201215001433/https://twitter.c...

I cannot find anything on what was done except shunning neonazis. Is that the extent?

I don't think calling her neonazi is fair.
Post reply on HN