Live data from Hacker News

Reality shifting: an emergent online daydreaming culture

link.springer.com

21–30 of 105 posts

Re: Reality shifting: an emergent online daydreaming culture

#21

Interesting to see them mention tulpas here. It's always been a bit of a meme online, but I knew a pretty tenured hypnotist who was utterly terrified of the things. He'd seen tulpas cause irreversible psychological damage to the people who adopted them, where many people would become completely attached to a character or particular fiction in their head. This could cause them to act out involuntarily, induce constant…

What's interesting about this stuff is that it seems to support interpretation through multiple cognitive frameworks. There could be a mystical/esoteric explanation for why those people became so attached to the characters or fictions. Or it could be that they were already vulnerable to schizophrenic or depersonalization/derealization-type disorders.

It's like how you'll sometimes hear/read people say that tantra/mediation stuff like Kundalini can be dangerous because it results in an energy imbalance that could potentially be irreparable and/or lead to lasting damage.

Re: Reality shifting: an emergent online daydreaming culture

#22

Many young females report joining Draco Malfoy as his girlfriend. Draco is a fictional character from the Harry Potter series, characterized as a cowardly bully who tricks and hurts people to get what he wants, a cunning user of magic. Were people paid to write this paper? It sounds like their research was browsing wattpad and reddit for an afternoon.

Funny, I thought that was one of the more interesting parts of the paper.

>It sounds like their research was browsing wattpad and reddit for an afternoon.

They explicitly say these are locations of the community in the paper. I don't think this invalidates anything. When performing contemporary anthropology, it is pretty common to observe subjects in their normal environment.

Re: Reality shifting: an emergent online daydreaming culture

#23

Interesting how occult concepts like astral travel (reality shifting) and familiars & daemons (tulpamancy) are getting recycled without the Victorian baggage.

It's funny because those things were couching certain phenomena (chiefly, being able to imagine things and, perhaps to an extent, hallucination due to external factors) into terms compatible with the dominant beliefs of the time (magicks of all sorts) while this is somewhat couched in the ideas of rationality and science, at least "reality shifting."

The Tulpa stuff has been reinterpreted in materialist terms too (apparently 80% of people treat it this way, from some study or other).

Of course, interpreting these things in just one way is a category mistake.

Re: Reality shifting: an emergent online daydreaming culture

#24

Wow, and here I am dropping cash on weed and shrooms like a chump. I’ll be honest, this strikes me as similar to the whole binaural sounds thing…I tried that way back in high school and got nothing from it but my friend swore it was elevating. I won’t knock it, I’m sure some people really do get something out of it and who and I to say otherwise. I might even try it some time. But shrooms haven’t ever let me down. So…

I always had this idea that meditation was the long way to the shortcut drugs offered. I am saying meditation, because, despite using fancy new terminology (RS)( ..[is] facilitated by specific induction methods involving relaxation, concentration of attention, and autosuggestion ), the paper does not really describe new phenomenon, but rather.. a new generation rediscovering 60s.

History. Rhymes. And all that.

Re: Reality shifting: an emergent online daydreaming culture

#25
Speaking of daydreaming, 2013 wasn't a great year for movies, so I was out of options when I went to see "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty" [1], and boy it turned out to be a great one.

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_Life_of_Walter_Mi...

Re: Reality shifting: an emergent online daydreaming culture

#26

Interesting to see them mention tulpas here. It's always been a bit of a meme online, but I knew a pretty tenured hypnotist who was utterly terrified of the things. He'd seen tulpas cause irreversible psychological damage to the people who adopted them, where many people would become completely attached to a character or particular fiction in their head. This could cause them to act out involuntarily, induce constant…

What's interesting about this stuff is that it seems to support interpretation through multiple cognitive frameworks. There could be a mystical/esoteric explanation for why those people became so attached to the characters or fictions. Or it could be that they were already vulnerable to schizophrenic or depersonalization/derealization-type disorders. It's like how you'll sometimes hear/read people say that tantra/med…

Yeah, the various explanations are a bit like geometry vs. algebra in maths. They're different tools for explaining the same things.

Re: Reality shifting: an emergent online daydreaming culture

#30

Wow, and here I am dropping cash on weed and shrooms like a chump. I’ll be honest, this strikes me as similar to the whole binaural sounds thing…I tried that way back in high school and got nothing from it but my friend swore it was elevating. I won’t knock it, I’m sure some people really do get something out of it and who and I to say otherwise. I might even try it some time. But shrooms haven’t ever let me down. So…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN