Live data from Hacker News

Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

wh0.github.io

41–50 of 62 posts

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#41
post #32

I see - once again, instead of just letting people fund the damn browser, Mozilla is continuing with its tried-and-true strategy of randomly integrating things into other things.

The number of ads for mozilla VPN in Firefox is getting to ridiculous levels, even when I explicit disable all "featured" stuff in options.

Fortunately, you can still get rid of all of them by disabling stuff in about:config

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#42
post #32

I see - once again, instead of just letting people fund the damn browser, Mozilla is continuing with its tried-and-true strategy of randomly integrating things into other things.

I’ve heard this comment so many times and had the same view. Then recently I found out they do take donations. Donate here for anyone who wants to :) I’d guess it’s not enough currently to cover for the millions they need to replace once they need to sunset their Google Search funding deal. https://donate.mozilla.org/en-AU/

It has been confirmed that none of the donated money (Mozilla Foundation) goes to Firefox development (Mozilla Corporation). You hear the comment often because it is true.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#43
There's no obvious reason to grant the nativeMessaging permission during extension installation for an optional feature, nativeMessaging can be declared as an optional permission since Firefox 87 [1], and Firefox Multi-Account Containers 8.0.2 only supports Firefox 91 or newer.

There could be a bug related to declaring nativeMessaging as an optional permission, though that is not mentioned in the pull request [2], so this was probably an oversight.

EDIT: the minimum supported version was bumped to Firefox 91 in a subsequent PR apparently not for technical reasons, but just to follow guidelines [3], and then they forgot to reevaluate the need for the new default permission before a release.

[1] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Add-ons/Web...

[2] https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/pull/215...

[3] https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/pull/218...

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#44
post #8

It's possible to benefit from containers without using the extension: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/containers#w_for-advanced-users

What functionality / convenience are you losing by doing so?

Without the extension, you can't set a domain to always open in a particular container, at least I couldn't find a UI to do so. To me, that is a very important part of using containers.

You extension also lets you sort open tabs by container but that doesn't sound very useful.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve heard this comment so many times and had the same view. Then recently I found out they do take donations. Donate here for anyone who wants to :) I’d guess it’s not enough currently to cover for the millions they need to replace once they need to sunset their Google Search funding deal. https://donate.mozilla.org/en-AU/

There's no option to donate to a specific project, though. As much as I'd like to support Firefox, I do not want to support any other shiny projects that they'll kiff of in a year or two.

[deleted]

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#46
post #32

I see - once again, instead of just letting people fund the damn browser, Mozilla is continuing with its tried-and-true strategy of randomly integrating things into other things.

I’ve heard this comment so many times and had the same view. Then recently I found out they do take donations. Donate here for anyone who wants to :) I’d guess it’s not enough currently to cover for the millions they need to replace once they need to sunset their Google Search funding deal. https://donate.mozilla.org/en-AU/

Donating to mozilla considered harmful.

https://itdm.com/mozilla-firefox-usage-down-85-but-why-are-e...

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#49

I would really like Firefox to implement granular permissions per extension. So, if I can choose to not give this extension permission to talk to external programs. And hopefully the extension authors wrote it in a way that it degrades gracefully.

This permission is harmless because native messaging only allows an extension to communicate with a specific native companion program that has to be installed/enabled outside if firefox. If you don't install the companion program, this permission won't do anything. It does not allow the extension to run arbitrary programs.

Where and how is this program specified? Can malware impersonate itself as a "companion program" and collect user activity data?

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve heard this comment so many times and had the same view. Then recently I found out they do take donations. Donate here for anyone who wants to :) I’d guess it’s not enough currently to cover for the millions they need to replace once they need to sunset their Google Search funding deal. https://donate.mozilla.org/en-AU/

Donating to mozilla considered harmful. https://itdm.com/mozilla-firefox-usage-down-85-but-why-are-e...

Wow ouch. Didn’t realise the exec were taking so much pay. Really disappointing.

Someone help me out.. where can we find the constitution for the Mozilla foundation?

Who makes up the voting membership who could act on this sort of stuff at a governance level?

Post reply on HN