Live data from Hacker News

Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

wh0.github.io

11–20 of 62 posts

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#11

I would really like Firefox to implement granular permissions per extension. So, if I can choose to not give this extension permission to talk to external programs. And hopefully the extension authors wrote it in a way that it degrades gracefully.

Bookmark access for the container extension is optional and there is a toggle button for it; for some reason, this one was added to the "Required permissions for core functionality" list which can not be modified.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#13
post #8

It's possible to benefit from containers without using the extension: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/containers#w_for-advanced-users

What functionality / convenience are you losing by doing so?

I think the menu in your toolbar that allows you to open a new tab in a particular container (you then have to do it via a long press or right-click on the new tab button), to re-open a current tab in a different container, and this new container-specific VPN functionality.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#14

It's possible to benefit from containers without using the extension: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/containers#w_for-advanced-users

I checked that page, and I don't see how to enable this natively. This page just seems to point people to install the add-on.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#15

I would really like Firefox to implement granular permissions per extension. So, if I can choose to not give this extension permission to talk to external programs. And hopefully the extension authors wrote it in a way that it degrades gracefully.

I'm not sure if it's possible for this permission yet, but it did become possible for extensions to dynamically requests access to page contents per site, rather than declaring them all up front. It requires the extension authors to use a different API though, which not everyone has switched to yet.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#16

It's possible to benefit from containers without using the extension: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/containers#w_for-advanced-users

I checked that page, and I don't see how to enable this natively. This page just seems to point people to install the add-on.

The anchor link doesn't scroll properly for me, but it's supposed to point to the heading "for advanced users".

The tl;dr is:

> you can set privacy.userContext.enabled to true and privacy.userContext.ui.enabled to true in about:config.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#17
post #7

Annoying change. Saw it yesterday and did not dare to accept. Good it comes up on HN, I might have forgotten. I have never looked into extensions. Could I just repackage it without requesting the additional privilege? Well, if the code called it unconditionally even if I don't really need it the extension would stop working.

Should be possible, but not sure if the code calls it unconditionally. You can also take the old version of the source code and publish it yourself. Though possibly you can also just download and install that directly? https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/releases...

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#18
post #8

It's possible to benefit from containers without using the extension: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/containers#w_for-advanced-users

What functionality / convenience are you losing by doing so?

Nothing. The containers support is in the WebExtension API.

Firefox's multi-account container extension has no special access, beyond usual extension permissions.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#19
post #9

I wish they fixed the long standing, annoying sync bug that makes Firefox download 7000+ containers every once in a while. Some of us hosed our sync accounts in one way or another (through the container duplication bug in m-a-c itself [1] or the temporary containers extension [2]) and it's impossible to recover - once you reach the storage quota on the sync server, the sync server refuses all write operations and del…

it is possible to recover! you just have to reset your account password, which blows away all server data, starting the quota over. but this is ok because you should still have a local copy, and when you log in with the new password you can upload that.

Re: Multi-Account Containers to “Exchange messages with programs other than Firefox”

#20
post #11

I would really like Firefox to implement granular permissions per extension. So, if I can choose to not give this extension permission to talk to external programs. And hopefully the extension authors wrote it in a way that it degrades gracefully.

Bookmark access for the container extension is optional and there is a toggle button for it; for some reason, this one was added to the "Required permissions for core functionality" list which can not be modified.

> for some reason

I think these permissions cannot be optional: https://extensionworkshop.com/documentation/develop/request-...

(Not sure though, I haven't worked with optional permissions for my extensions yet.)

Post reply on HN